Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
-
- Posts: 429
- Joined: Sun Jun 17, 2012 2:14 pm
Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
I’m not necessarily planning on this but here’s a hypothetical question I had.
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
What would you do with the extra money?
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
If you stop ira contributions x 2, and spend the extra $12k / year, and assuming you continue with the extra $12k / year spending through retirement you’d need an extra $300k in your portfolio, assuming a 4% withdrawal rate.
Also, I’d use a real return (subtracting inflation) for your estimated portfolio balances. Vanguard’s projections for us equities are 4.4-6.6% return/ year with an projected inflation rate of (10 year average) of 2-3% / year, giving a real rate of 1.4%- 4.6% / year. If you re-ran your projections with a return of 2% with upper bound of 5% the numbers at 55 and 65 wouldn’t be as attractive.
https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/ ... -2023.html
Also, I’d use a real return (subtracting inflation) for your estimated portfolio balances. Vanguard’s projections for us equities are 4.4-6.6% return/ year with an projected inflation rate of (10 year average) of 2-3% / year, giving a real rate of 1.4%- 4.6% / year. If you re-ran your projections with a return of 2% with upper bound of 5% the numbers at 55 and 65 wouldn’t be as attractive.
https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/ ... -2023.html
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
A couple of thoughts:
1) By reducing contributions now, you are making a critical assumption that you will be able to work (and contribute a reduced amount) consistently through retirement. That of course isn't always the case, and recovering from job loss can get more difficult as you get older depending on career.
2) Does spending more now increase or decrease your spending expectations in retirement? If your retirement target isn't changing, and you spend more today, does that mean that there will be a larger reduction in lifestyle from your freespending ways to your target retirement lifestyle.
3) Are you sure you have no interest in retiring early? For many people, a couple years of "freedom" is more valuable than incremental consumption.
4) This decision feels like a high class version of the "One More Year" decision
1) By reducing contributions now, you are making a critical assumption that you will be able to work (and contribute a reduced amount) consistently through retirement. That of course isn't always the case, and recovering from job loss can get more difficult as you get older depending on career.
2) Does spending more now increase or decrease your spending expectations in retirement? If your retirement target isn't changing, and you spend more today, does that mean that there will be a larger reduction in lifestyle from your freespending ways to your target retirement lifestyle.
3) Are you sure you have no interest in retiring early? For many people, a couple years of "freedom" is more valuable than incremental consumption.
4) This decision feels like a high class version of the "One More Year" decision
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
We chose to keep the pedal to the medal. And thank goodness we did. DH, the higher earner by far, has developed fibromyalgia and can no longer work a desk job full time. He isn't even 40 yet, but it's fine because we are FI for our current lifestyle. His has currently opted for semi retirement mostly because they asked him to and he loves being an engineer.
This is not the early retirement option we were saving for, but we are glad we saved.
The key is to be frugal without being miserable. Do things you enjoy, spend here and there where it has maximum impact on your satisfaction. We spent quite a bit on outdoor chairs that we often take to a park to sit and read and enjoy the view.
This is not the early retirement option we were saving for, but we are glad we saved.
The key is to be frugal without being miserable. Do things you enjoy, spend here and there where it has maximum impact on your satisfaction. We spent quite a bit on outdoor chairs that we often take to a park to sit and read and enjoy the view.
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
TarHeel2002,TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am I’m not necessarily planning on this but here’s a hypothetical question I had.
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
A) Why would you choose to pay more taxes?
B) How much is your portfolio in the tax deferred account? Only the amount in the Trad 401K need to be counted.
C) What is your asset allocation in the Trad 401K account?
D) Is it possible that your calculation is wrong? Please show us your calculation.
E) What is your marginal tax rate?
F) Do you pay state income tax?
KlangFool
Last edited by KlangFool on Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:37 am, edited 1 time in total.
30% VWENX | 16% VFWAX/VTIAX | 14.5% VTSAX | 19.5% VBTLX | 10% VSIAX/VTMSX/VSMAX | 10% VSIGX| 30% Wellington 50% 3-funds 20% Mini-Larry
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Absolutely - say it louder for the people in the back! To me, heavy investing early on was a bit discouraging, but it takes some time for the returns to really start piling up. The first time my account growth outpaced my contributions was an exciting moment!TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
In my opinion using a 6% return is good for estimating future account balances, because it somewhat takes inflation into account when estimating in todays dollars. In reality, it'll probably be more like 8% growth with 2% inflation....... or 9% growth with 3% inflation or something like that.
You have my permission to take the foot off the gas. It all depends on your goals for spending. Do you want to retire ASAP? Then keep saving heavily. Are you OK with working until 55 or 65 in order to spend more now? Really it's a personal question and a matter of goals.
"The one who covets is the poorer man, |
For he would have that which he never can; |
But he who doesn't have and doesn't crave |
Is rich, though you may hold him but a knave." - Wife of Bath tale
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Be wary of 15-25 year projections. It’s better to keep the pedal to the metal until you make it, or at least ratchet down to a 15-20% savings level. Then once you make it you can readjust whether you want to increase consumption while working, call it quits, or somewhere in between.
-
- Posts: 980
- Joined: Mon Dec 26, 2022 11:45 am
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
I agree with KlangFool.KlangFool wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:34 amTarHeel2002,TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am I’m not necessarily planning on this but here’s a hypothetical question I had.
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
A) Why would you choose to pay more taxes?
...
KlangFool
I kept 'pedal to the metal' filling pre-tax accounts, avoiding federal taxes of 22% (sometimes 25%).
Now early-retired, I annually convert those same pre-tax dollars, plus their earnings, into Roth status at federal tax cost of 12% (and less).
Was a no-brainer for me.
Good luck with your decision.
Age<59.5. Early-retired. AA ~55/45. Taxable account, Roth IRA, HSA...all are 100% equities. 100% of fixed income is in tIRA. I spend from taxable and re-balance in tIRA.
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Wait until you are at around 20x before you start taking chances like this. It’s way to risky making assumption on full employment so far out.
A time to EVALUATE your jitters: |
viewtopic.php?p=1139732#p1139732
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
8-10 more years of saving as much as possible, then re-evaluate. You could have a 40 year retirement.
If you have a vested pension, that changes things, but I didn't read that you do.
If you have a vested pension, that changes things, but I didn't read that you do.
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
The amounts in Roth and HSA accounts don't matter in terms of whether you have "too much" in your pre-tax accounts.TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return.
You could start with a Simple method to estimate your taxable income from pre-tax withdrawals. As noted there, a hand calculator would suffice for a first approximation.
See the following link for slightly more complicated back-of-the-envelope calculations, and a Detailed method description for yet more.
Until your expected marginal tax rate in retirement reaches your marginal tax saving rate due to traditional contributions now, you don't have "too much" in those pre-tax accounts. Does that make sense?
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
I did similar math a few years ago and I came to the conclusion that I should start doing some Roth 401k contributions.TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am I’m not necessarily planning on this but here’s a hypothetical question I had.
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
A time to EVALUATE your jitters: |
viewtopic.php?p=1139732#p1139732
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Tough to answer not knowing your income or expenses
“Conventional Treasury rates are risk free only in the sense that they guarantee nominal principal. But their real rate of return is uncertain until after the fact.” -Risk Less and Prosper
-
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Thu May 18, 2017 11:49 am
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
I would recommend you redirect your savings to taxable. Do that for a while and see how you feel. If you are still on track then spend more.
I do not agree with traditional retirement in 2023.
There are so many interesting things to do and ways to make money. You did the hard part. Don’t touch that money and let it grow but for sure spend now and don’t wait.
I do not agree with traditional retirement in 2023.
There are so many interesting things to do and ways to make money. You did the hard part. Don’t touch that money and let it grow but for sure spend now and don’t wait.
-
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Thu May 18, 2017 11:49 am
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Should have said I did this and am so much happier. It was depressing thinking of waiting until 60.
Have healthy assets outside of retirement now and growing. Don’t feel stressed at work, excited about next decade, not holding my breath for 60 and what will be in my golden years.
Have healthy assets outside of retirement now and growing. Don’t feel stressed at work, excited about next decade, not holding my breath for 60 and what will be in my golden years.
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Employers do not match taxable contributions. Or Roth contributions (though you can make them in a workplace plan and the employer will match in pre-tax, if the plan supports Roth.)broncocountry25 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 8:25 pm I would recommend you redirect your savings to taxable. Do that for a while and see how you feel. If you are still on track then spend more.
I do not agree with traditional retirement in 2023.
There are so many interesting things to do and ways to make money. You did the hard part. Don’t touch that money and let it grow but for sure spend now and don’t wait.
-
- Posts: 429
- Joined: Sun Jun 17, 2012 2:14 pm
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Income = 280-300k
Core expenses 115-125k …but we spend more than this if you include travel, home improvements, entertainment etc
Saving 71k annually in retirement accounts
Saving 15-18k annually for 529 accounts (currently have 160k)
1290k is broken down as follows:
785k = 401(k)
272k = Roth
107k = brokerage
66k = HSA
22k = cash
44k = ibonds
Core expenses 115-125k …but we spend more than this if you include travel, home improvements, entertainment etc
Saving 71k annually in retirement accounts
Saving 15-18k annually for 529 accounts (currently have 160k)
1290k is broken down as follows:
785k = 401(k)
272k = Roth
107k = brokerage
66k = HSA
22k = cash
44k = ibonds
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
TarHeel2002,TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 12:49 pm Income = 280-300k
Core expenses 115-125k …but we spend more than this if you include travel, home improvements, entertainment etc
Saving 71k annually in retirement accounts
Saving 15-18k annually for 529 accounts (currently have 160k)
1290k is broken down as follows:
785k = 401(k)
272k = Roth
107k = brokerage
66k = HSA
22k = cash
44k = ibonds
Only 785K of the 401K is taxable upon withdrawal in retirement.
If you withdraw 4% per year, it is only 31.4K per year. How much taxes do you pay with 31.4K of taxable income per year in retirement?
Unless you enjoy paying a lot more taxes, why would you stop contributing to 401K?
KlangFool
30% VWENX | 16% VFWAX/VTIAX | 14.5% VTSAX | 19.5% VBTLX | 10% VSIAX/VTMSX/VSMAX | 10% VSIGX| 30% Wellington 50% 3-funds 20% Mini-Larry
-
- Posts: 288
- Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2018 8:07 pm
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
1290k/125k = ~10.TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 12:49 pm Income = 280-300k
Core expenses 115-125k …but we spend more than this if you include travel, home improvements, entertainment etc
Saving 71k annually in retirement accounts
Saving 15-18k annually for 529 accounts (currently have 160k)
1290k is broken down as follows:
785k = 401(k)
272k = Roth
107k = brokerage
66k = HSA
22k = cash
44k = ibonds
I would suggest not let up until you are nearing 25x.
I am of the opinion that one should "make hay while the sun shines". We are of similar age but have ~30x saved, save >1x per year and have a vested federal pension. Perhaps I am too much of a fraidy-cat but I am as of now not comfortable taking my foot off the pedal. Tomorrow may bring an unexpected financial hardship I will be better prepared for by continuing to save now while I am able. If such hardship does not come to pass then mayhaps I'll have the option of a retirement date earlier than planned.
"Yeah, well, you know, that's just like, uh, your opinion, man." - J. Lebowski
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
I would even consider 20x and then let compounding do the rest. I would never even consider it at ~10x where OP appears to be hanging out. Way too many unknowns for this.makeitcount wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 4:30 pm1290k/125k = ~10.TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 12:49 pm Income = 280-300k
Core expenses 115-125k …but we spend more than this if you include travel, home improvements, entertainment etc
Saving 71k annually in retirement accounts
Saving 15-18k annually for 529 accounts (currently have 160k)
1290k is broken down as follows:
785k = 401(k)
272k = Roth
107k = brokerage
66k = HSA
22k = cash
44k = ibonds
I would suggest not let up until you are nearing 25x.
I am of the opinion that one should "make hay while the sun shines". We are of similar age but have ~30x saved, save >1x per year and have a vested federal pension. Perhaps I am too much of a fraidy-cat but I am as of now not comfortable taking my foot off the pedal. Tomorrow may bring an unexpected financial hardship I will be better prepared for by continuing to save now while I am able. If such hardship does not come to pass then mayhaps I'll have the option of a retirement date earlier than planned.
Just to point out I am a proponent of a 4% withdrawal rate mixed with flexibility. At least that is how we have lived our lives.
A time to EVALUATE your jitters: |
viewtopic.php?p=1139732#p1139732
-
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Thu May 18, 2017 11:49 am
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
Yes I am aware employers don’t match a brokerage account. I contribute up to the match at work, do backdoor Roth IRAs, the rest into taxable/real estate.Admiral wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 9:25 amEmployers do not match taxable contributions. Or Roth contributions (though you can make them in a workplace plan and the employer will match in pre-tax, if the plan supports Roth.)broncocountry25 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 8:25 pm I would recommend you redirect your savings to taxable. Do that for a while and see how you feel. If you are still on track then spend more.
I do not agree with traditional retirement in 2023.
There are so many interesting things to do and ways to make money. You did the hard part. Don’t touch that money and let it grow but for sure spend now and don’t wait.
My goals are not to have the highest amount possible at 60 but to smooth my spending over time and avoid working away the early years of my life.
Even doing this at the current moment I only defer 4% to 401k and employer puts in 9% so 13% total.
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
+1000 to Bolded-and-underlined text.EnjoyIt wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 4:13 pmI did similar math a few years ago and I came to the conclusion that I should start doing some Roth 401k contributions.TarHeel2002 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 10:17 am I’m not necessarily planning on this but here’s a hypothetical question I had.
42 years old and currently have 1.29 million in investments. Up to this point we’ve been maxing 401(k) x 2, Roth IRA x 2 and HSA (71k annually)
I was inputting some numbers and if I just do the current HSA max and get my 401(k) match ($13,300 annually) I end up with roughly 2.6 million by 55 and 4.8 million by 65 @ 6% return. I realize I’m making a few assumptions here on returns and employment.
It seems like those numbers would be sufficient for us. It’s so interesting to me how important it is to get started saving early and let compound interest do the heavy lifting later on.
Do I keep on with pedal to the metal or back off a bit??
If you feel you have more than sufficient pre-tax contributions in the 401(k), start doing Roth 401(k) contributions instead. But never let the tax-advantaged space go waste (assuming you have funds to contribute).
Re: Only maxing out HSA + 401(k) match going forward?
At that income level, it seems like maxing out retirement accounts is barely noticeable. We have about that much income and max out our 401k and HSA without even noticing it. The long term benefits of that are going to be sweet. No way I’d give up a single penny of that tax advantaged space.