+1UpperNwGuy wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 3:40 pmThat's crazy talk! $50,000 is nothing in a high cost of living area. I spend nearly double that amount (including taxes). You must live in a very low cost of living area.
For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Re: How much do you spend annually in retirement?
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: How much do you spend annually in retirement?
I asked and the response was simply COBRA. Time to start interviewing I guess...ResearchMed wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 4:49 pmYes, you'd probably want to ask HR for their *current* retiree health benefits.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 4:29 pm I know it sounds silly, but how do I check what my employer offers? I've switched companies a handful of times, but I never checked what they would offer post-leaving, as I was always switching to the next gig w/ health insurance.
I briefly browsed around our internal benefits site but I didn't see anything along those lines (which is reasonable, why would they talk about health benefits after leaving to current employees).
Is this something I have to ping the HR / Payroll / Benefits type people and get a response?
But keep in mind that the benefits could change.
Ours did, and significantly for some of the younger/newer employees. When they retire, their retiree health benefits will cover considerably less of costs that would be submitted than the plan does now, or what it will cover for the now-older employees when they retire, etc.
And who knows if there will be yet more changes looming in the future...
RM
-
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2017 12:42 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
these numbers make more sense to me.kilkoyne wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 5:11 pm This is showing 2019 numbers because 2020 was not normal with Covid. The $2k hospital bill in 2019 was not a normal occurrence either but I included it. Outside of medical insurance I probably only spend $100/year.
My health insurance is appr $60/PPD ($60 x 26 = $1,560/year). My coworker on the other hand spends 14K/year for family. I'm a nurse and take care of myself - Rarely ever go to primary care. If I have an issue I run it by the docs at work. My one medication, lab work, and care visits are all covered by insurance.
The only thing than is not included is heat. I have a wood stove with plenty of wood on my lot to last my lifetime. At some point I'll have to but oil though when I'm sick of burning wood.
Automotive Expenses $159.58 (Cheap Honda Civic and a used truck which are easy and cheap to fix)
Bills & utilities $3,160.00 (Car/Home/Health Ins/Electric)
Food & drink $261.66 (I don't go out to eat often, I prefer making my own meals)
Gas $1,215.56
Groceries $900.34
Health & wellness $1,958.49 (Not a normal expenditure, I had a Hospital Admission in 2019)
Home $7,564.58 (Allow 7K/year for home improvements -Bought kitchen cabinets and maple flooring which I installed myself)
Shopping $1,112.50 (Everyday things and some tools and stuff that I like)
Travel $3,106.12 (Allow myself 3K/year to travel)
"Rent"/Mortgage $18,000.00
Internet $1,650.00
Total $39,088.83
Do you live in US, don't you?
If you take off the rent/mortgage (let's say one day you'll own an house and no debt) you would spend 21K per year that about the same I spend per year in northern Italy.
Since I read here that most people are spending 60K to 90K per year, and they retire with 50x expenses which means 3-5 million $ I was just wondering if this one is the situation of the average American.
When I study English I am lazier than my portfolio. Feel free to fix my English and investing mistakes.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
"Since I read here that most people are spending 60K to 90K per year, and they retire with 50x expenses which means 3-5 million $ I was just wondering if this one is the situation of the average American."InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 1:02 pmthese numbers make more sense to me.kilkoyne wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 5:11 pm This is showing 2019 numbers because 2020 was not normal with Covid. The $2k hospital bill in 2019 was not a normal occurrence either but I included it. Outside of medical insurance I probably only spend $100/year.
My health insurance is appr $60/PPD ($60 x 26 = $1,560/year). My coworker on the other hand spends 14K/year for family. I'm a nurse and take care of myself - Rarely ever go to primary care. If I have an issue I run it by the docs at work. My one medication, lab work, and care visits are all covered by insurance.
The only thing than is not included is heat. I have a wood stove with plenty of wood on my lot to last my lifetime. At some point I'll have to but oil though when I'm sick of burning wood.
Automotive Expenses $159.58 (Cheap Honda Civic and a used truck which are easy and cheap to fix)
Bills & utilities $3,160.00 (Car/Home/Health Ins/Electric)
Food & drink $261.66 (I don't go out to eat often, I prefer making my own meals)
Gas $1,215.56
Groceries $900.34
Health & wellness $1,958.49 (Not a normal expenditure, I had a Hospital Admission in 2019)
Home $7,564.58 (Allow 7K/year for home improvements -Bought kitchen cabinets and maple flooring which I installed myself)
Shopping $1,112.50 (Everyday things and some tools and stuff that I like)
Travel $3,106.12 (Allow myself 3K/year to travel)
"Rent"/Mortgage $18,000.00
Internet $1,650.00
Total $39,088.83
Do you live in US, don't you?
If you take off the rent/mortgage (let's say one day you'll own an house and no debt) you would spend 21K per year that about the same I spend per year in northern Italy.
Since I read here that most people are spending 60K to 90K per year, and they retire with 50x expenses which means 3-5 million $ I was just wondering if this one is the situation of the average American.
A few stats based on 2020 data:
$43.8K - median household (HH) income in retirement
$67.2K - mean HH income in retirement
$34.8K - median HH income for 75+ year old
$54.4K - mean HH income for 75+ year old
The figures for average and median were incorrectly switched - they are now corrected above and below.
Last edited by smitcat on Fri Apr 09, 2021 8:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Even though Bogleheads are an affluent bunch, assuming that most of us retire with 50X expenses is drawing the wrong conclusion.InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 1:02 pmthese numbers make more sense to me.kilkoyne wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 5:11 pm This is showing 2019 numbers because 2020 was not normal with Covid. The $2k hospital bill in 2019 was not a normal occurrence either but I included it. Outside of medical insurance I probably only spend $100/year.
My health insurance is appr $60/PPD ($60 x 26 = $1,560/year). My coworker on the other hand spends 14K/year for family. I'm a nurse and take care of myself - Rarely ever go to primary care. If I have an issue I run it by the docs at work. My one medication, lab work, and care visits are all covered by insurance.
The only thing than is not included is heat. I have a wood stove with plenty of wood on my lot to last my lifetime. At some point I'll have to but oil though when I'm sick of burning wood.
Automotive Expenses $159.58 (Cheap Honda Civic and a used truck which are easy and cheap to fix)
Bills & utilities $3,160.00 (Car/Home/Health Ins/Electric)
Food & drink $261.66 (I don't go out to eat often, I prefer making my own meals)
Gas $1,215.56
Groceries $900.34
Health & wellness $1,958.49 (Not a normal expenditure, I had a Hospital Admission in 2019)
Home $7,564.58 (Allow 7K/year for home improvements -Bought kitchen cabinets and maple flooring which I installed myself)
Shopping $1,112.50 (Everyday things and some tools and stuff that I like)
Travel $3,106.12 (Allow myself 3K/year to travel)
"Rent"/Mortgage $18,000.00
Internet $1,650.00
Total $39,088.83
Do you live in US, don't you?
If you take off the rent/mortgage (let's say one day you'll own an house and no debt) you would spend 21K per year that about the same I spend per year in northern Italy.
Since I read here that most people are spending 60K to 90K per year, and they retire with 50x expenses which means 3-5 million $ I was just wondering if this one is the situation of the average American.
One thing that humbles me deeply is to see that human genius has its limits while human stupidity does not. - Alexandre Dumas, fils
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
What's the difference between "average" and "mean" here? Should one of those be "median" ?
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Corrected below...
Last edited by smitcat on Fri Apr 09, 2021 8:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
You are correct , here is one link but not the orginal one scratched some notes from above....sailaway wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 8:15 pmAre you sure? Usually for these kinds of things, the mean is higher than the median.
https://www.personalcapital.com/blog/re ... nt-income/
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Irrespective of the numbers, seems like it is going to be more and more important to look at spending, rather than income, as fewer people have pensions and hopefully more have savings, in a mix of traditional, Roth and taxable accounts.
-
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2017 12:42 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Thank you, interesting.smitcat wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 2:48 pm A few stats based on 2020 data:
$43.8K - median household (HH) income in retirement
$67.2K - mean HH income in retirement
$34.8K - median HH income for 75+ year old
$54.4K - mean HH income for 75+ year old
The figures for average and median were incorrectly switched - they are now corrected above and below.
Is the income gross? What's the average tax you pay on it?
In this way we can deduct the mean and median net income.
I have also read here "...the average monthly Social Security payment by only $20 to $1,543". If social security is 18K$ per year, I suppose most of the income in retirement comes from a portfolio/401k of savings (and maybe rental propreties).
It seems to be pretty expensive to retire in US nowadays.
When I study English I am lazier than my portfolio. Feel free to fix my English and investing mistakes.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Awesome thread...I'm going to take a much closer look at our current spending and projected spending in retirement. We would like to keep our income in retirement at the 12% tax bracket and hopefully not exceed it, roughly 80k. Im a state worker with both a pension and a 457 account. Spouse has a 401k. We have additional accounts as well. Retirement for both of us is within 1-2 years, I'm currently 60, wife is 51. We live in an HCOL area, that will change when retired. We do like travel, and are currently leaving tomorrow for Aruba. We have a few more trips already planned this year. Will post some figures later today and see how we compare with others.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 3:13 amThank you, interesting.smitcat wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 2:48 pm A few stats based on 2020 data:
$43.8K - median household (HH) income in retirement
$67.2K - mean HH income in retirement
$34.8K - median HH income for 75+ year old
$54.4K - mean HH income for 75+ year old
The figures for average and median were incorrectly switched - they are now corrected above and below.
Is the income gross? What's the average tax you pay on it?
In this way we can deduct the mean and median net income.
I have also read here "...the average monthly Social Security payment by only $20 to $1,543". If social security is 18K$ per year, I suppose most of the income in retirement comes from a portfolio/401k of savings (and maybe rental propreties).
It seems to be pretty expensive to retire in US nowadays.
It appears to be problematic to retire in Italy now, not too optimistic at all ....
"According to our survey, retirees in Italy are also the least happy when it comes to being
able to afford the lifestyle they want in retirement. Almost 50% of retired respondents
stated they are unhappy with this aspect of retirement, the highest out of the eight
countries we looked at."
Source of quote and data:
https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pd ... apshot.pdf
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Until the year before I retired, I had never paid any attention to my “retirement number”. I simply saved a significant portion of our income, and after 10 years of trying investments, like rental real estate, for which I was not temperamentally suited, I evolved into paassive stock market investing. 25 years of saving and indexing and ignoring market fluctuations worked out well.
When I looked at our retirement funds, I decided that a 3% withdrawal rate would be safe and allow us to enjoy some of the fruits of our savings. This amounted to 150% of what we were spending prior to retirement. And after a couple of years, I realized that of that 150%, I was still putting aside, or underspending,10%. Can t break old habits.
On Medicare, with IRMAA, our monthly medical insurance costs are about $1400 a month. About what I was paying through my business prior to retirement. And significantly more than I was paying prior to the enactment of ACA.
My wife has a tiny pension from her old employer, and we have Social Security.
When I looked at our retirement funds, I decided that a 3% withdrawal rate would be safe and allow us to enjoy some of the fruits of our savings. This amounted to 150% of what we were spending prior to retirement. And after a couple of years, I realized that of that 150%, I was still putting aside, or underspending,10%. Can t break old habits.
On Medicare, with IRMAA, our monthly medical insurance costs are about $1400 a month. About what I was paying through my business prior to retirement. And significantly more than I was paying prior to the enactment of ACA.
My wife has a tiny pension from her old employer, and we have Social Security.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
US here. When I retire I'll have more time to grow my own food and cut wood for heat, complete house projects, cook myself nice meals, play my guitar, etc. I could live on $20K/year with my house paid off until I wasn't able to take care for myself. I don't believe anyone "needs" 3-5 million to retire but some feel it's necessary.InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Fri Apr 09, 2021 1:02 pmthese numbers make more sense to me.kilkoyne wrote: ↑Thu Apr 08, 2021 5:11 pm This is showing 2019 numbers because 2020 was not normal with Covid. The $2k hospital bill in 2019 was not a normal occurrence either but I included it. Outside of medical insurance I probably only spend $100/year.
My health insurance is appr $60/PPD ($60 x 26 = $1,560/year). My coworker on the other hand spends 14K/year for family. I'm a nurse and take care of myself - Rarely ever go to primary care. If I have an issue I run it by the docs at work. My one medication, lab work, and care visits are all covered by insurance.
The only thing than is not included is heat. I have a wood stove with plenty of wood on my lot to last my lifetime. At some point I'll have to but oil though when I'm sick of burning wood.
Automotive Expenses $159.58 (Cheap Honda Civic and a used truck which are easy and cheap to fix)
Bills & utilities $3,160.00 (Car/Home/Health Ins/Electric)
Food & drink $261.66 (I don't go out to eat often, I prefer making my own meals)
Gas $1,215.56
Groceries $900.34
Health & wellness $1,958.49 (Not a normal expenditure, I had a Hospital Admission in 2019)
Home $7,564.58 (Allow 7K/year for home improvements -Bought kitchen cabinets and maple flooring which I installed myself)
Shopping $1,112.50 (Everyday things and some tools and stuff that I like)
Travel $3,106.12 (Allow myself 3K/year to travel)
"Rent"/Mortgage $18,000.00
Internet $1,650.00
Total $39,088.83
Do you live in US, don't you?
If you take off the rent/mortgage (let's say one day you'll own an house and no debt) you would spend 21K per year that about the same I spend per year in northern Italy.
Since I read here that most people are spending 60K to 90K per year, and they retire with 50x expenses which means 3-5 million $ I was just wondering if this one is the situation of the average American.
To me life is about life experiences and spending time with family and friends. In many ways money would likely just get in the way of this.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Tax planning to minimize taxes is a good thing, like taking withdrawals to buy a new car over 2 years to avoid slipping into the next marginal bracket if you took everything out in one year.Bbddl wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 5:53 am Awesome thread...I'm going to take a much closer look at our current spending and projected spending in retirement. We would like to keep our income in retirement at the 12% tax bracket and hopefully not exceed it, roughly 80k. Im a state worker with both a pension and a 457 account. Spouse has a 401k. We have additional accounts as well. Retirement for both of us is within 1-2 years, I'm currently 60, wife is 51. We live in an HCOL area, that will change when retired. We do like travel, and are currently leaving tomorrow for Aruba. We have a few more trips already planned this year. Will post some figures later today and see how we compare with others.
But why would you have a goal of keeping your retirement income in the 12% bracket? I’d be thrilled if we were in the 37% bracket!
One thing that humbles me deeply is to see that human genius has its limits while human stupidity does not. - Alexandre Dumas, fils
-
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2015 8:55 pm
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
I'm 59 and have been retired for six years. I track my expenses through Personal Capital. We budget ourselves $17,500 a month, or $210,000 a year for everything -- including taxes, health insurance, etc. I
n 2020 we spent $217,978. In 2019 we spent $224,545. In 2018 we spent $167,857. Obviously we went a little over budget the last two years but 2018 was a very lean year so we allowed ourselves to do it. The bulk of the extra expenses in 2019 and 2020 were home improvement expenses (61k). Taking them out, our annual expenses have averaged:
Mortgage: $28k (we've elected not to pay if off because our interest rate is low)
Healhcare: 26k (includes premiums and out of pockets)
Travel: 20k (lower in 2020 than 2019 and 2018 obviously)
Taxes: 17k (income and property combined)
Home maintenance: 14k (including a one-off $8000 paintjob in 2020)
General merchandise: 12k
Restaurants: 9k
Automotive 9k
Groceries 8k
Spending on kids/grandkids: 6k
Utilities: 5k
Pet care: 4k
Cable/internet: 4k
Gifts: 4k
Cell phones: 3k (half reimbursed by kids on family plan)
Home/umbrella insurance: 1.6k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
n 2020 we spent $217,978. In 2019 we spent $224,545. In 2018 we spent $167,857. Obviously we went a little over budget the last two years but 2018 was a very lean year so we allowed ourselves to do it. The bulk of the extra expenses in 2019 and 2020 were home improvement expenses (61k). Taking them out, our annual expenses have averaged:
Mortgage: $28k (we've elected not to pay if off because our interest rate is low)
Healhcare: 26k (includes premiums and out of pockets)
Travel: 20k (lower in 2020 than 2019 and 2018 obviously)
Taxes: 17k (income and property combined)
Home maintenance: 14k (including a one-off $8000 paintjob in 2020)
General merchandise: 12k
Restaurants: 9k
Automotive 9k
Groceries 8k
Spending on kids/grandkids: 6k
Utilities: 5k
Pet care: 4k
Cable/internet: 4k
Gifts: 4k
Cell phones: 3k (half reimbursed by kids on family plan)
Home/umbrella insurance: 1.6k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
I'm thinking how can you spend 4k/year on cable/internet? YouTubeTV and unlimited 1Gbps internet costs me about 120/month.BigLaw Survivor wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:41 am
Cable/internet: 4k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
- fishnskiguy
- Posts: 2635
- Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 12:27 pm
- Location: Castle Rock, CO
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
For some of us, that's not unreasonable. Dish TV (no cable available) with Showtime and Stars bundled with internet at a paltry 7-8 MPS plus landline phone runs us $3500 per year.kelway wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:51 amI'm thinking how can you spend 4k/year on cable/internet? YouTubeTV and unlimited 1Gbps internet costs me about 120/month.BigLaw Survivor wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:41 am
Cable/internet: 4k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
Chris
Trident D-5 SLBM- "When you care enough to send the very best."
-
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2015 8:55 pm
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
I should clarify that we split our time between two houses . . .kelway wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:51 amI'm thinking how can you spend 4k/year on cable/internet? YouTubeTV and unlimited 1Gbps internet costs me about 120/month.BigLaw Survivor wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:41 am
Cable/internet: 4k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
-
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2017 12:42 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
It won't be a problem because every 20 years in Italy we have a financial crisis caused by the huge Debt to GDP ratio, bad goverment management, corruption, 12 years decreasing GDP and 20 years decreasing GDP per capita. Since the biggest share of Government expenses are public pensions, on each crisis they cut the public pensions and push them further away in time.smitcat wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 6:51 amIt appears to be problematic to retire in Italy now, not too optimistic at all ....
"According to our survey, retirees in Italy are also the least happy when it comes to being
able to afford the lifestyle they want in retirement. Almost 50% of retired respondents
stated they are unhappy with this aspect of retirement, the highest out of the eight
countries we looked at."
Source of quote and data:
https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pd ... apshot.pdf
My dad retired at 60. But I won't see a penny before being 67.5 years old. People younger than me won't see a penny before being in their 70s.
So basically retirement is not a problem anymore because we all be dead before we'll be able to retire.
I'm saving, and hopefully I'll retire early.
Do you mind if I share the document you posted on an Italian board? It's a board somehow similar to Bogleheads.
When I study English I am lazier than my portfolio. Feel free to fix my English and investing mistakes.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
24% federal and 9.3% state = 33.3% - so $40k tax = $120k. Simplified, but close, given investment income, too.Escapevelocity wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 7:24 am
$40K tax on a pension???? How much is the pension $200k?
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Keep your eye on https://www.starlink.com/ if you're not already... I assume you're rural. This will be a big deal for rural folks. YouTubeTV is really great according to me -- once you have the internet to support it.fishnskiguy wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 11:21 am
For some of us, that's not unreasonable. Dish TV (no cable available) with Showtime and Stars bundled with internet at a paltry 7-8 MPS plus landline phone runs us $3500 per year.
Chris
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
OK OK clear...BigLaw Survivor wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 11:24 am I should clarify that we split our time between two houses . . .
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
"Do you mind if I share the document you posted on an Italian board? It's a board somehow similar to Bogleheads."InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 4:13 pmIt won't be a problem because every 20 years in Italy we have a financial crisis caused by the huge Debt to GDP ratio, bad goverment management, corruption, 12 years decreasing GDP and 20 years decreasing GDP per capita. Since the biggest share of Government expenses are public pensions, on each crisis they cut the public pensions and push them further away in time.smitcat wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 6:51 amIt appears to be problematic to retire in Italy now, not too optimistic at all ....
"According to our survey, retirees in Italy are also the least happy when it comes to being
able to afford the lifestyle they want in retirement. Almost 50% of retired respondents
stated they are unhappy with this aspect of retirement, the highest out of the eight
countries we looked at."
Source of quote and data:
https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pd ... apshot.pdf
My dad retired at 60. But I won't see a penny before being 67.5 years old. People younger than me won't see a penny before being in their 70s.
So basically retirement is not a problem anymore because we all be dead before we'll be able to retire.
I'm saving, and hopefully I'll retire early.
Do you mind if I share the document you posted on an Italian board? It's a board somehow similar to Bogleheads.
No problem - I found it with a simple search in a few seconds, there are plenty of articles about the issues with Italy's retirement approach.
"It won't be a problem because every 20 years in Italy we have a financial crisis caused by the huge Debt to GDP ratio"
The article basically says very few are happy with retirement, very few are prepared, very few think its their responsability and that it is getting worse.
IMHO - I prefer a more 'expensive' retirement where I am.
-
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2017 12:42 pm
- Location: Italy
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
It's been only a few years since the Social Security in Italy made it easy for people to know the pension they will receive and when they will retire. Now we can login on Social Security website and see it straight away.
Before you had to do all sort of calculus on your own by reading hundreds of laws that explained how to calculate it, or you had fo pay a CPA 25 to 50 euro to do it for you.
I think more and more people in Italy are becoming aware they will retire with tiny pensions hence they are starting to realize they need a private pension. The problem is that private pension schemes started only recently, there are only few pension funds available, they are quite expensive and when you put money in these private pension scheme the tax deduction is still ridicolous.
Anyway I asked for details on expenses because in year 2000 I worked in CA for a couple of years, and I don't remember life to be so expensive there, besides the rent and the healthcare.
The salaries were higher than in Italy.
Would you say that now, 20 years later, is much more expensive to live in US than in year 2000?
When I study English I am lazier than my portfolio. Feel free to fix my English and investing mistakes.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
"Would you say that now, 20 years later, is much more expensive to live in US than in year 2000?"InvestInPasta wrote: ↑Tue Apr 13, 2021 3:45 amIt's been only a few years since the Social Security in Italy made it easy for people to know the pension they will receive and when they will retire. Now we can login on Social Security website and see it straight away.
Before you had to do all sort of calculus on your own by reading hundreds of laws that explained how to calculate it, or you had fo pay a CPA 25 to 50 euro to do it for you.
I think more and more people in Italy are becoming aware they will retire with tiny pensions hence they are starting to realize they need a private pension. The problem is that private pension schemes started only recently, there are only few pension funds available, they are quite expensive and when you put money in these private pension scheme the tax deduction is still ridicolous.
Anyway I asked for details on expenses because in year 2000 I worked in CA for a couple of years, and I don't remember life to be so expensive there, besides the rent and the healthcare.
The salaries were higher than in Italy.
Would you say that now, 20 years later, is much more expensive to live in US than in year 2000?
There are 10's of thousands of places to live and compare costs in the USA - some starting at a very LCOL and rising to a very HCOL, so you have huge choices to make which will determine many costs. As far as general costs (which may or may not apply) they have risen about 48% in the past 20 years or so, you can utilize calculators such as these to get general inflation numbers for costs over time
https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Well, by most measures YouTubeTV isn't cable for one thing.kelway wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:51 amI'm thinking how can you spend 4k/year on cable/internet? YouTubeTV and unlimited 1Gbps internet costs me about 120/month.BigLaw Survivor wrote: ↑Sat Apr 10, 2021 10:41 am
Cable/internet: 4k
As you can see, there's a lot to think about.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
This has been a great thread. I was thinking the following which is $111,400 per year but would love feedback.
$7,2000 Car gas/maintenance (a little more than what we spend now)
$6,240 Gardening/Home Cleaning (about what we spend now)
$2,160 Cellular Bills (about what we spend now)
$15,000 Vacation Fund (about what we spend now)
$3,600 Misc Monthly expenses/house maintenance (about what we spend now)
$19,200 Groceries/Eating Out (about 20-40% more than what we spend now)
$9,600 Car Fund (about what we spend now) assuming you own two cars and keep for a decade
$18,600 Daily ($50 per day fund) (about what we spend now)
$3,400 Yearly Costs Like Car Insurance/Termite & Pet Control (about what we spend now)
$9,600 Utilities/TV/Internet (more than what we spend now)
$16,800 Home Insurance/Property Taxes (about what we spend now)
Now thinking I have not included health insurance. Anything else - appears higher than most have quoted.
Thank you...
$7,2000 Car gas/maintenance (a little more than what we spend now)
$6,240 Gardening/Home Cleaning (about what we spend now)
$2,160 Cellular Bills (about what we spend now)
$15,000 Vacation Fund (about what we spend now)
$3,600 Misc Monthly expenses/house maintenance (about what we spend now)
$19,200 Groceries/Eating Out (about 20-40% more than what we spend now)
$9,600 Car Fund (about what we spend now) assuming you own two cars and keep for a decade
$18,600 Daily ($50 per day fund) (about what we spend now)
$3,400 Yearly Costs Like Car Insurance/Termite & Pet Control (about what we spend now)
$9,600 Utilities/TV/Internet (more than what we spend now)
$16,800 Home Insurance/Property Taxes (about what we spend now)
Now thinking I have not included health insurance. Anything else - appears higher than most have quoted.
Thank you...
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
You spend $50/day on top of eating out and transportation? What kind of thing does that include?dpusa wrote: ↑Tue Apr 13, 2021 2:43 pm This has been a great thread. I was thinking the following which is $111,400 per year but would love feedback.
$7,2000 Car gas/maintenance (a little more than what we spend now)
$6,240 Gardening/Home Cleaning (about what we spend now)
$2,160 Cellular Bills (about what we spend now)
$15,000 Vacation Fund (about what we spend now)
$3,600 Misc Monthly expenses/house maintenance (about what we spend now)
$19,200 Groceries/Eating Out (about 20-40% more than what we spend now)
$9,600 Car Fund (about what we spend now) assuming you own two cars and keep for a decade
$18,600 Daily ($50 per day fund) (about what we spend now)
$3,400 Yearly Costs Like Car Insurance/Termite & Pet Control (about what we spend now)
$9,600 Utilities/TV/Internet (more than what we spend now)
$16,800 Home Insurance/Property Taxes (about what we spend now)
Now thinking I have not included health insurance. Anything else - appears higher than most have quoted.
Thank you...
I was also curious as to what $180/month of cellular gets you. Does that include payments for the phones? A separate hotspot?
Yes, I am nosy.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
There’s another current thread on budgeting.dpusa wrote: ↑Tue Apr 13, 2021 2:43 pm This has been a great thread. I was thinking the following which is $111,400 per year but would love feedback.
$7,2000 Car gas/maintenance (a little more than what we spend now)
$6,240 Gardening/Home Cleaning (about what we spend now)
$2,160 Cellular Bills (about what we spend now)
$15,000 Vacation Fund (about what we spend now)
$3,600 Misc Monthly expenses/house maintenance (about what we spend now)
$19,200 Groceries/Eating Out (about 20-40% more than what we spend now)
$9,600 Car Fund (about what we spend now) assuming you own two cars and keep for a decade
$18,600 Daily ($50 per day fund) (about what we spend now)
$3,400 Yearly Costs Like Car Insurance/Termite & Pet Control (about what we spend now)
$9,600 Utilities/TV/Internet (more than what we spend now)
$16,800 Home Insurance/Property Taxes (about what we spend now)
Now thinking I have not included health insurance. Anything else - appears higher than most have quoted.
Thank you...
We have a budget and one reason is that it would drive me nuts to be spending $50 per day — almost $20,000/year — that I couldn’t identify.
Although maybe you can. Clothes, jewelry?
One thing that humbles me deeply is to see that human genius has its limits while human stupidity does not. - Alexandre Dumas, fils
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
It achieves the same goal and is, by most measures, a superior product. If you prefer to pay twice the price for coax, feel very free.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
My category list, compiled through the years:dpusa wrote: ↑Tue Apr 13, 2021 2:43 pm This has been a great thread. I was thinking the following which is $111,400 per year but would love feedback.
$7,2000 Car gas/maintenance (a little more than what we spend now)
$6,240 Gardening/Home Cleaning (about what we spend now)
$2,160 Cellular Bills (about what we spend now)
$15,000 Vacation Fund (about what we spend now)
$3,600 Misc Monthly expenses/house maintenance (about what we spend now)
$19,200 Groceries/Eating Out (about 20-40% more than what we spend now)
$9,600 Car Fund (about what we spend now) assuming you own two cars and keep for a decade
$18,600 Daily ($50 per day fund) (about what we spend now)
$3,400 Yearly Costs Like Car Insurance/Termite & Pet Control (about what we spend now)
$9,600 Utilities/TV/Internet (more than what we spend now)
$16,800 Home Insurance/Property Taxes (about what we spend now)
Now thinking I have not included health insurance. Anything else - appears higher than most have quoted.
Thank you...
House:
Mortgage
Property Taxes
Property Insurance
Condo/HOA fees
Home repairs & maintenance
Firewood delivery
Heating Oil
Lawn Care
Termite/Pest service
Tree trimming, 2x per year
Housekeeper
Utilities:
Heat, Water, Gas, Electric
Cable, internet
Cell phone
Security system
Food:
Food & toiletries, Grocery store
Food - restaurants
Health Food, vitamins, supplements
Automotive:
Auto insurance
Auto repair
Car registration
Smogging
Gasoline
Charitable giving
Taxes:
Tax prep fees
Income Tax, Fed
Income Tax, State
Medical:
Health Insurance
Medical Deductible
Medicare Co-Pays
Co-Pays & Prescriptions
Glasses
Chiropractor
Dental
Life Insurance
LTC Insurance
Media & Entertainment:
Books, CD's
Movies - theater
Movies - streaming services: Netflix, HULU, Prime, HBO, Disney +
Computer software/replacement fund
Personal Care:
Hair stylist
Mani/Pedis
Clothing
Dry Cleaning
Subscriptions:
Costco
AAA
Newspaper/NY Times online
Remote backup service - iDrive
Ring Doorbell
Miscellaneous:
Wine and alcohol
Family Gifts
Pet and Vet costs
Hobbies:
Travel
Camping
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Also note this thread, which started up while this one was dormant:
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=345321 [Link broken, see below --admin LadyGeek]
My responses are there, which is why I haven't posted here.
[added: now I see that I have posted here after all. ]
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=345321 [Link broken, see below --admin LadyGeek]
My responses are there, which is why I haven't posted here.
[added: now I see that I have posted here after all. ]
Last edited by 22twain on Thu Apr 15, 2021 9:20 am, edited 1 time in total.
Meet my pet, Peeve, who loves to convert non-acronyms into acronyms: FED, ROTH, CASH, IVY, ...
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
(^^^ The merge broke the link.)
I merged bg5's thread into the ongoing discussion. The combined thread is in the Personal Finance (Not Investing) forum (retirement spending).
(Thanks to the member who reported the post and provided the link to this thread.)
I merged bg5's thread into the ongoing discussion. The combined thread is in the Personal Finance (Not Investing) forum (retirement spending).
(Thanks to the member who reported the post and provided the link to this thread.)
- ResearchMed
- Posts: 16795
- Joined: Fri Dec 26, 2008 10:25 pm
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Perhaps put a "LadyGeek Comment" in that post above, right next to the now-dead-end link, so we don't each separately click on that and each separately find out the link goes... nowhere... before reading your comment in the next post? [Done --admin LadyGeek ]LadyGeek wrote: ↑Thu Apr 15, 2021 6:22 am (^^^ The merge broke the link.)
I merged bg5's thread into the ongoing discussion. The combined thread is in the Personal Finance (Not Investing) forum (retirement spending).
(Thanks to the member who reported the post and provided the link to this thread.)
Thanks!
RM
This signature is a placebo. You are in the control group.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
TLDR
When our future pension and portfolio income equaled our current spending, we retired. Our current spending was calculated by subtracting our annual savings from our entire current income, knowing the remainder was spent somewhere.
Our retirement spending amount was chosen to be a slowing increasing % of each recent annual portfolio value, thus slightly variable income but those small annual income adjustments are insuring portfolio longevity. The percentage is longevity based using the IRS's RMD (Required Minimum Distribution) rate for my age, plus spending the dividends and interest easily seen on brokerage statements. There are RMD numbers for all ages due to inherited IRAs that the heirs are required to slowly withdraw for taxes.
Sun and Webb at Boston College's Center for Retirement Research developed the RMD % plus interest and dividend spending method.
As our portfolio value fluctuates, we can see in advance whether next year's income will be more or less than this year's number.
When our future pension and portfolio income equaled our current spending, we retired. Our current spending was calculated by subtracting our annual savings from our entire current income, knowing the remainder was spent somewhere.
Our retirement spending amount was chosen to be a slowing increasing % of each recent annual portfolio value, thus slightly variable income but those small annual income adjustments are insuring portfolio longevity. The percentage is longevity based using the IRS's RMD (Required Minimum Distribution) rate for my age, plus spending the dividends and interest easily seen on brokerage statements. There are RMD numbers for all ages due to inherited IRAs that the heirs are required to slowly withdraw for taxes.
Sun and Webb at Boston College's Center for Retirement Research developed the RMD % plus interest and dividend spending method.
As our portfolio value fluctuates, we can see in advance whether next year's income will be more or less than this year's number.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Sorry for the late bump of this thread, but I was looking for a place to post this recent summary of a 2015 UK research finding: https://monevator.com/spending-decline-in-retirement/. Here's an overall summary:
FYI, other references:A big but oft-overlooked question for aspiring retirees is: “Will my spending decline in retirement?” If the answer is yes, then you could retire sooner than you think, or you could spend more money in the early years after your own freedom day.
As it happens, there’s a large stack of research that suggests people really do see their spending decline in retirement. At least on average.
And if this turns out to be you, then the amount you need to retire should be less daunting than previously advertised. You can even afford to decrease your ‘how much should I put in my pension’ target figure.
- BH's wiki covers (mostly US?) surveys of this sort: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Surveys ... t_spending
- a thread: Older retirees: Are your expenses lower now than in early retirement?
- another thread: How much money is really needed in retirement?
- and another: Poll of the retirees among us--spending in retirement
Please donate to support BH! https://bogleheads.org/support.php
-
- Posts: 3187
- Joined: Tue Dec 21, 2010 2:55 pm
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Mic Drop Moment Right Here! Why on earth do we have so much agony here on BH? How many of you who are prolific poster here anticipate or have trouble meeting that number when *all sources of income are included*?Rick Ferri wrote: ↑Mon Jan 04, 2021 9:58 amI speak with hundreds of retirees each year. Most are HNW individuals or couples. The median budget in retirement is about $70,000 - this includes travel but does not include income tax or gifts. Only about 10% of the retirees I speak with spend more than $100,000 per year, and that's usually because they have two homes or travel extensively.Does anybody spend significantly more than $90k/year in retirement?
Rick Ferri
-
- Posts: 3944
- Joined: Fri Dec 20, 2019 2:49 am
- Location: Upstate NY
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
This is like asking - how long is a string? Well it depends.
We can afford about X and that is what we spend. If we could afford 2X we would take nicer vacations and buy nicer cars and houses. I don’t know what we would spend if we could afford 100X. I guess at some point one would stop buying stuff or stop giving away stuff although McKenzie Bezos seems to keep giving away stuff.
We can afford about X and that is what we spend. If we could afford 2X we would take nicer vacations and buy nicer cars and houses. I don’t know what we would spend if we could afford 100X. I guess at some point one would stop buying stuff or stop giving away stuff although McKenzie Bezos seems to keep giving away stuff.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Because median or average budgets for retirees as a whole — even affluent ones — have no meaning for individual BH retirees?wrongfunds wrote: ↑Tue Apr 19, 2022 4:05 pmMic Drop Moment Right Here! Why on earth do we have so much agony here on BH? How many of you who are prolific poster here anticipate or have trouble meeting that number when *all sources of income are included*?Rick Ferri wrote: ↑Mon Jan 04, 2021 9:58 amI speak with hundreds of retirees each year. Most are HNW individuals or couples. The median budget in retirement is about $70,000 - this includes travel but does not include income tax or gifts. Only about 10% of the retirees I speak with spend more than $100,000 per year, and that's usually because they have two homes or travel extensively.Does anybody spend significantly more than $90k/year in retirement?
Rick Ferri
Individual retirees don’t care whether their income can cover the average budget; they worry about whether it can cover their own. And they worry about portfolio sustainability, of course.
One thing that humbles me deeply is to see that human genius has its limits while human stupidity does not. - Alexandre Dumas, fils
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Agreed. The dollar figure itself also doesn't tell you all that much without getting into the line items details of household spending. Someone could spend $100K a year with a mortgage in one location and have a lower standard of living that someone else living off of $40K in another place debt-free.Parkinglotracer wrote: ↑Tue Apr 19, 2022 4:19 pm This is like asking - how long is a string? Well it depends.
We can afford about X and that is what we spend. If we could afford 2X we would take nicer vacations and buy nicer cars and houses. I don’t know what we would spend if we could afford 100X. I guess at some point one would stop buying stuff or stop giving away stuff although McKenzie Bezos seems to keep giving away stuff.
Once you get past a certain point I think it makes more sense to focus on withdrawal rate rather than the dollar figures since it gives you a better idea of how much spending buffer (or portfolio crash buffer) you have. If you're drawing 2%, then you've got safe headroom to spend on whims and wants, but if you're pushing 4 or 5% then you've likely got more risk to consider.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Update: Our total last year [2021] was about $56K.22twain wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 5:46 pm We're retired, late 60s / early 70s, in a small town in the South, with a paid-off house.
Last year [2020] we spent a total of about $53K, of which:
$8K income tax (fed + state)
$12K donations (charitable + political)
$7K Medicare premiums
$9K housing-related (utilities, property tax, insurance, maintenance)
$3K food (no eating out because of Covid)
$14K everything else (cars, new computers, hobbies, etc.)
If it hadn't been for Covid, we would have spent more for eating out and travel.
Only one of us is collecting Social Security and taking RMDs from tax-deferred accounts. After the other one starts in a few years, our tax bill will probably increase to about $30K.
Compared to the previous year I can remember the following major changes:
- $1K less in income tax because my wife stopped teaching part time after spring 2020
- $4K less for "everything else" because of not buying new computers
- $8K more because of putting a new roof on the house
In both years we had no major travel. Last year I did some solo day trips to hobby shows in the region, which get lumped in under "everything else".
Meet my pet, Peeve, who loves to convert non-acronyms into acronyms: FED, ROTH, CASH, IVY, ...
Re: How much do you spend annually in retirement?
I think I have my own numbers worked out pretty well, yet to me this thread is very helpful. It shows me how other people, including some already in retirement, approaching this issue, what they are considering, how they are calculating, and it is a lot of food for thought and analysis. The actual numbers may indeed be irrelevant, but based on the experiences and thinking that I read about here I can play with my own numbers.thursdaysd wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:38 amAgreed. I spent nearly that much on "eating out" last year, and I'm single. "Eating out" being curb-side pickup from local restaurants, with higher-than-usual tips. My grocery bill was much higher, but that included more than food.
It really demonstrates that there is a huge variation, and the OP needs to start with his current expenditures and not worry too much about other people.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
I removed an off-topic post. As a reminder, see: General Etiquette
At all times we must conduct ourselves in a respectful manner to other posters. Attacks on individuals, insults, name calling, trolling, baiting or other attempts to sow dissension are not acceptable.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Here is our budget after one year of retirement. Age 56 & 52. Add $20k for taxes and $25k for travel.
Consistently sets low goals and fails to achieve them.
-
- Posts: 3944
- Joined: Fri Dec 20, 2019 2:49 am
- Location: Upstate NY
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
/month
Consistently sets low goals and fails to achieve them.
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
One of the things I discovered early in a long career in math and physics, is that you usually must actually run the numbers for the applicable case to determine the correct answer. No amount of table-topping discussion will ever suffice. Everyone at the table is either ignorant or makes things up to get their way. In the case of your own spending you are everyone at the table.
For personal finance, this means creating a budget (spending model) from the top down (total all actual expenditures including savings and taxes) and from the bottom up (create spending categories and then assign savings, spending, and tax values to each). The numbers from both methods must be close, or you do not understood your own spending.
For personal finance, this means creating a budget (spending model) from the top down (total all actual expenditures including savings and taxes) and from the bottom up (create spending categories and then assign savings, spending, and tax values to each). The numbers from both methods must be close, or you do not understood your own spending.
Like good comrades to the utmost of their strength, we shall go on to the end. -- Winston Churchill
Re: For those retired or FI, how much do you spend annually?
Thanks very much for this input Rick. I very much value your books and opinions here. I have always heard 80% of your current spending but have 4 kids and a mortgage. and if I use that get 100k/yr. Has always seemed excessive to me and thought I was over saving especially when I hear what “physician on fire” is spending and heat what he is doing still. Good to know I am not crazy thinking $80k a year is more than plenty after taxes. Makes me think my wife is right and we can live more for today.Rick Ferri wrote: ↑Mon Jan 04, 2021 9:58 amI speak with hundreds of retirees each year. Most are HNW individuals or couples. The median budget in retirement is about $70,000 - this includes travel but does not include income tax or gifts. Only about 10% of the retirees I speak with spend more than $100,000 per year, and that's usually because they have two homes or travel extensively.Does anybody spend significantly more than $90k/year in retirement?
Rick Ferri