Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Good evening,
I can't think of a better way to spend a Friday night than to ask with humility a seemingly simple math problem. Please join me.
I'm buying a new car. Family has outgrown the current car. I have a 3yr old car to trade in. It is paid off.
New Car:
Retail $48,154
Accessories $279
Sale Price $48,433
Document fee $394
Registration fee $184.87
TAX $2,905.98
OTD Price $51,917.45
Dealer offer for trade in is $33,000. This will save me $1,980 in tax
CarMax offer for trade in is $37,000.
Is selling to CarMax the better deal?
I paid $36000 OTD for current car. Do I pay capital gains on the OTD price I paid for it? Bought OTD $36,000. Sold for $37,000. Pay tax on $1,000 dollars? What would the rate be?
Since Carmax will pay me $4,000 more, and that outweighs the $1,980 tax savings, is it better?
So, 15% of 1000 is $150. It seems clear that I should sell to Carmax for $4000 more and pay the $150 capital gains, correct?
First timer selling a used car for gains...
I can't think of a better way to spend a Friday night than to ask with humility a seemingly simple math problem. Please join me.
I'm buying a new car. Family has outgrown the current car. I have a 3yr old car to trade in. It is paid off.
New Car:
Retail $48,154
Accessories $279
Sale Price $48,433
Document fee $394
Registration fee $184.87
TAX $2,905.98
OTD Price $51,917.45
Dealer offer for trade in is $33,000. This will save me $1,980 in tax
CarMax offer for trade in is $37,000.
Is selling to CarMax the better deal?
I paid $36000 OTD for current car. Do I pay capital gains on the OTD price I paid for it? Bought OTD $36,000. Sold for $37,000. Pay tax on $1,000 dollars? What would the rate be?
Since Carmax will pay me $4,000 more, and that outweighs the $1,980 tax savings, is it better?
So, 15% of 1000 is $150. It seems clear that I should sell to Carmax for $4000 more and pay the $150 capital gains, correct?
First timer selling a used car for gains...
-
- Posts: 3487
- Joined: Sun Sep 11, 2016 11:27 am
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
You can ask the dealer if they'll match or at least come closer to the CarMax figure.
-
- Posts: 18502
- Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 6:05 am
- Location: 26 miles, 385 yards west of Copley Square
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
But did you have a gain?
Did you pay for:
gas
oil
inspection sticker
any maintenance
tires
registration
taxes
I really doubt you spent less than $150 on the car, thus, I see no gain.
As mentioned, ask the dealer to match the car max price. If you're still concerned with the gain, have the dealer pay you $4k less for your trade but charge you $4k less for the car you're buying. That's completely legit. The only thing the dealer cares about is the difference you're paying.
Did you pay for:
gas
oil
inspection sticker
any maintenance
tires
registration
taxes
I really doubt you spent less than $150 on the car, thus, I see no gain.
As mentioned, ask the dealer to match the car max price. If you're still concerned with the gain, have the dealer pay you $4k less for your trade but charge you $4k less for the car you're buying. That's completely legit. The only thing the dealer cares about is the difference you're paying.
Bogle: Smart Beta is stupid
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I haven't researched this, but contra Jack FFR, I doubt you can add ordinary usage and maintenance costs to your basis.
I think in the more common case of a HOUSE you buy and sell for a gain (outside of the $250K exclusion or whatever), you can add actual improvements to your basis (putting a garage on a house that didn't have one), but not maintenance (painting your house or whatever).
But do your own research.
===
Back to the car trade-in. In some states (like mine, Missouri), you can get a sales tax credit even when you don't do a trade in. i.e. Buy car from dealer A, sell different car to private party, or dealer B, within a given time window, and deduct the sales price of different car from newly bought car for sales tax purposes.
I think in the more common case of a HOUSE you buy and sell for a gain (outside of the $250K exclusion or whatever), you can add actual improvements to your basis (putting a garage on a house that didn't have one), but not maintenance (painting your house or whatever).
But do your own research.
===
Back to the car trade-in. In some states (like mine, Missouri), you can get a sales tax credit even when you don't do a trade in. i.e. Buy car from dealer A, sell different car to private party, or dealer B, within a given time window, and deduct the sales price of different car from newly bought car for sales tax purposes.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I've never heard of an individual paying capital gains on a used car sale. How would the IRS even know? Does Carmax report the sale? I sold my truck to Carmax last year for 6k more than I paid for it in 2020. It never even crossed my mind I might be taxed on the gain.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
It never crossed my mind either until I read it somewhere on here. I guess if the IRS really wanted to know where a lump $37K came from in my bank account...AussieDad wrote: ↑Sat Jan 22, 2022 1:48 am I've never heard of an individual paying capital gains on a used car sale. How would the IRS even know? Does Carmax report the sale? I sold my truck to Carmax last year for 6k more than I paid for it in 2020. It never even crossed my mind I might be taxed on the gain.
I'll be paying the same amount to the dealer no matter what. MSRP or bust nowadays it seems. They'll sell it to someone tomorrow if I don't pay the agreed upon price. I will ask them to match the trade in value of Carmax. If they don't, obviously I'm going to sell to Carmax instead of them and use the proceeds to buy the new car.Jack FFR1846 wrote: ↑Fri Jan 21, 2022 8:39 pm But did you have a gain?
Did you pay for:
gas
oil
inspection sticker
any maintenance
tires
registration
taxes
I really doubt you spent less than $150 on the car, thus, I see no gain.
As mentioned, ask the dealer to match the car max price. If you're still concerned with the gain, have the dealer pay you $4k less for your trade but charge you $4k less for the car you're buying. That's completely legit. The only thing the dealer cares about is the difference you're paying.
Yes, I did pay for gas, inspection/emission, taxes when I bought it etc...
I didn't know this counted against any capital gains(which I calculate to be $1,000 and a capital gains tax of $150)
-
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2016 7:14 am
- Location: Chicago Metro
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Seems to me that no one but you will have all the historical data from which a capital gain could be calculated: original purchase price and sale price of old car.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I've lost money on every car I've owned.
Have I missed the boat on deducting capital losses?
Not a serious question.
Have I missed the boat on deducting capital losses?
Not a serious question.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Sell to CarMax. Pocket the excess value over trade in. Treat yourself to a nice dinner.
Better yet, at least explore selling to an online outfit like Carvana. When my family sold cars a couple of years ago, Carvana beat CarMax, and the experience was very positive. Don’t know if Carvana continues to be so aggressive in buying cars, but it can’t hurt to ask.
Better yet, at least explore selling to an online outfit like Carvana. When my family sold cars a couple of years ago, Carvana beat CarMax, and the experience was very positive. Don’t know if Carvana continues to be so aggressive in buying cars, but it can’t hurt to ask.
Retired life insurance company financial executive who sincerely believes that ”It’s a GREAT day to be alive!”
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
On the Carvana website they help explain the tax issue.
https://blog.carvana.com/2020/03/what-t ... a-vehicle/
https://blog.carvana.com/2020/03/what-t ... a-vehicle/
-
- Posts: 5463
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 8:56 am
- Location: North Carolina
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I have had dealers match Carmax price on trade ins. My impression is that Carmax offers are very credible to dealers. See what the dealer will do.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Taxes are an issue in CT. That is, you save on sales tax by trading in with the dealer your buy from (unlike MO). Ask the dealer you are buying from.
My gut says "try" this.
Search for your new car you want nationwide on CarMax. It may cost more than dealer or may cost less. (include delivery fees in your analysis).
My gut says "try" this.
Search for your new car you want nationwide on CarMax. It may cost more than dealer or may cost less. (include delivery fees in your analysis).
"Owning the stock market over the long term is a winner's game. Attempting to beat the market is a loser's game. ..Don't look for the needle in the haystack. Just buy the haystack." Jack Bogle
-
- Posts: 3487
- Joined: Sun Sep 11, 2016 11:27 am
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Taxation doesn't depend on whether the IRS knows about the income or not.
Historically it would be very uncommon for used cars (excluding collectibles) to be sold for a gain, so you would likely not have heard about it.
Last edited by SlowMovingInvestor on Sat Jan 22, 2022 8:44 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 3487
- Joined: Sun Sep 11, 2016 11:27 am
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
They don't have to exactly match the trade in value, just enough to compensate for the tax difference. Also, a little less hassle selling to the dealer since you can avoid going to a (possibly far away) Carmax locationjw2s wrote: ↑Sat Jan 22, 2022 4:55 am I will ask them to match the trade in value of Carmax. If they don't, obviously I'm going to sell to Carmax instead of them and use the proceeds to buy the new car.
Yes, I did pay for gas, inspection/emission, taxes when I bought it etc...
I didn't know this counted against any capital gains(which I calculate to be $1,000 and a capital gains tax of $150)
I'm not a tax expert, but I don't see how you can add gas or regular maintenance etc. to the basis. You should be able to add the tax and fees you paid when buying. And you should be able to add any upgrades (not replacements) you did. And any prep work/maintenance you did after deciding to sell the car.
I'm unsure whether you can add any interest on any car loan you might have paid. For houses, you can't add that, BUT you get a deduction for mortgage interest every year, so you've already claimed a deduction.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
This is the question:
Trade in for $33K which would save me $1,980 in taxes
Or
Sell to carmax for $37k, realize a $1,000 LTCG, and owe $150 in taxes next year?
This seems to be a new thing-used car sales now becoming capital gains!
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
So, if they offer me $35,000 for the trade in and save me $2,000 in taxes, is that the same as selling to Carmax for $37,000?SlowMovingInvestor wrote: ↑Sat Jan 22, 2022 8:43 amThey don't have to exactly match the trade in value, just enough to compensate for the tax difference. Also, a little less hassle selling to the dealer since you can avoid going to a (possibly far away) Carmax locationjw2s wrote: ↑Sat Jan 22, 2022 4:55 am I will ask them to match the trade in value of Carmax. If they don't, obviously I'm going to sell to Carmax instead of them and use the proceeds to buy the new car.
Yes, I did pay for gas, inspection/emission, taxes when I bought it etc...
I didn't know this counted against any capital gains(which I calculate to be $1,000 and a capital gains tax of $150)
-
- Posts: 1167
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2019 9:09 am
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I think you are over thinking it. I would sell to CARMAX or CARVANA and be done with it. The dealer will get you no matter what.
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
I am NOT a tax expert. But to be clear. The tax thing I am talking about is sales tax. If you trade in a car in Connecticut, the trade in value is deducted from the new car price to determine sales tax. If you sell the car elsewhere (on your own) you can subtract that value. There are some new limits on this.
Base on what you wrote. To save $1980 in taxes, I suspect you are able to deduct the trade in value from your car cost in your state as well (with a 5 to 6 percent sales tax rate).
This is why you may want to see if there is anything equivalent at CarMax. Get the max trade, best car deal, and sales tax deduction.
I was NOT talking about LTCG. I do not think you need to claim this. But I do not know.
"Owning the stock market over the long term is a winner's game. Attempting to beat the market is a loser's game. ..Don't look for the needle in the haystack. Just buy the haystack." Jack Bogle
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
First things first. Get the dealer to match Carmax. Remember the dealer definitely wants the used car. Selling used cars is the dealer’s second most profitable area behind their service department.
-
- Posts: 902
- Joined: Tue Mar 27, 2018 5:41 am
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
USED CAR SALES and TAXES
I'm not a tax expert but my understanding
I'm not a tax expert but my understanding
- IRS
Yes. Cars are considered "Personal Use Property". If you sell a car for more than it's adjusted cost then, technically, the IRS says you should declare it on Schedule D and be taxed. However, if you have a loss you can't declare it because it's Personal Use Property. Personal use property includes items that you do not use for business purposes and did not acquire for investment purposes. For example, your car, home, coin and stamp collection and jewelry.- Adjusted cost = Price you paid + Cost of permanent improvements (like a new stereo). Maintenance costs (such as new tires) and repairs aren't improvements
- I'm not telling you what to do but, in practice, unlikely the IRS would know of any gain
- What to know about taxes when you sell a vehicle
- STATE
- Maybe. Some states tax private car sales (e.g. Illinois taxes amounts over $10,000) so double check your state
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Thanks for all the help everyone!
The dealer matched carmax. BTW, carvana was $10(TEN) thousand lower so be sure to search all of them if selling your car.
Now I don't have to deal with that pesky LTCG for a used car!
The dealer matched carmax. BTW, carvana was $10(TEN) thousand lower so be sure to search all of them if selling your car.
Now I don't have to deal with that pesky LTCG for a used car!
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Bought a new Toyota Dec of last year.
Carmax was offering 32,500 for my car outright, showed it to the dealer and got an additional $500.
New car was MSRP, no negotiating so to me it was easy, plus the dealer let me keep the car until my new one was built.
Carmax was offering 32,500 for my car outright, showed it to the dealer and got an additional $500.
New car was MSRP, no negotiating so to me it was easy, plus the dealer let me keep the car until my new one was built.
-
- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2016 5:16 pm
Re: Trade in car v sell to Carmax math
Consider taking the carmax offer to dealer and see if they match it as someone noted above. Pre pandemic I did this