Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Are individual packets of laundry detergent, whether in a powder or liquid form, superior in cleaning ability to a liquid bottle or box of powder of same brand detergent? Were individual packets primarily created for convenience purposes (not having to handle a heavy bottle or box)?
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Sounds like a science fair project for the kids.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I would say that it is probably consumer convenience and for associated profits.
We use liquid detergent - at our previous home our septic manufacturer recommended liquid soaps and he have stuck with it even in our new town home.
I suppose powder in cardboard boxes may be better for the environment not being bottled in plastic
We use liquid detergent - at our previous home our septic manufacturer recommended liquid soaps and he have stuck with it even in our new town home.
I suppose powder in cardboard boxes may be better for the environment not being bottled in plastic
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I used to use liquid but switched to pods after a liquid detergent container started leaking. Pods are super convenient, though price per load is higher.
-
- Posts: 5993
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2016 3:22 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Convenience, plain and simple.
Same detergent inside.
Same detergent inside.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Quite some time ago I read that the recommended amounts of dishwasher and washing machine detergents were about 2-3 times more than necessary, so I have been using less since then with good results. With the packets, you don't have that choice unless you save half in a dish or something.
- ResearchMed
- Posts: 16795
- Joined: Fri Dec 26, 2008 10:25 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
We use a fraction of the "recommended amount" of detergent for laundry.egrets wrote: ↑Sun Apr 25, 2021 6:35 pm Quite some time ago I read that the recommended amounts of dishwasher and washing machine detergents were about 2-3 times more than necessary, so I have been using less since then with good results. With the packets, you don't have that choice unless you save half in a dish or something.
(We don't have small children who are getting clothing really filthy, which would be different.)
We don't do this to save money, although it does save a bit on the detergent cost, which isn't a big cost overall to start with for us.
We do it so that we don't have detergent residue in our clothing and linens.
Try washing towels, for example, with no detergent at all, and peek inside (for front loader, just peer in with flashlight) to see if there are suds. Fabric tends to be softer when there isn't residue.
In the dishwasher, if the dishes aren't heavily soiled, we use a very small amount of dish washing powder (same would be for liquid). Dishes and glasses come out very clean. (You can see that especially on glassware.)
I'm pretty convinced that a major impetus to the "convenient pre-packaged packets" of <whatever> are usually to sell more of <whatever>; convenience is probably secondary.
RM
This signature is a placebo. You are in the control group.
-
- Posts: 4074
- Joined: Fri Jan 29, 2016 11:40 am
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Check the label on your container of pods. The recommended amount is usually 2 pods for regular loads or 3 pods for heavy loads. Using 1 pod is already going "light" on the amount, no need to cut in half.egrets wrote: ↑Sun Apr 25, 2021 6:35 pm Quite some time ago I read that the recommended amounts of dishwasher and washing machine detergents were about 2-3 times more than necessary, so I have been using less since then with good results. With the packets, you don't have that choice unless you save half in a dish or something.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
*shrug* I like the "Tide Pods" (for laundry, although they do have an oddly sweet odor to them ) They're very convenient, pre-portioned, and easy to carry a couple if I'm going to be doing laundry somewhere else. I actually think I get better results (fresher smelling clothes) from them compared to the liquid detergents. I prefer liquid detergents, it seems like I get better results. I've heard powdered detergents don't work as well since the ban on using phosphates in U.S. detergents.
Last edited by JoMoney on Sun Apr 25, 2021 8:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"To achieve satisfactory investment results is easier than most people realize; to achieve superior results is harder than it looks." - Benjamin Graham
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
+1 - sensitive skin. It works better for me to use less detergent and no softener.ResearchMed wrote: ↑Sun Apr 25, 2021 6:56 pmWe use a fraction of the "recommended amount" of detergent for laundry.egrets wrote: ↑Sun Apr 25, 2021 6:35 pm Quite some time ago I read that the recommended amounts of dishwasher and washing machine detergents were about 2-3 times more than necessary, so I have been using less since then with good results. With the packets, you don't have that choice unless you save half in a dish or something.
(We don't have small children who are getting clothing really filthy, which would be different.)
We don't do this to save money, although it does save a bit on the detergent cost, which isn't a big cost overall to start with for us.
We do it so that we don't have detergent residue in our clothing and linens.
Try washing towels, for example, with no detergent at all, and peek inside (for front loader, just peer in with flashlight) to see if there are suds. Fabric tends to be softer when there isn't residue.
In the dishwasher, if the dishes aren't heavily soiled, we use a very small amount of dish washing powder (same would be for liquid). Dishes and glasses come out very clean. (You can see that especially on glassware.)
I'm pretty convinced that a major impetus to the "convenient pre-packaged packets" of <whatever> are usually to sell more of <whatever>; convenience is probably secondary.
RM
Bigger is better
We buy the big packets
https://www.mieleusa.com/e/miele-ultrap ... 10803670-p
Precise control of dosage.
Excellent Persil detergent (Euro version).
Ease of use is great.
We have no residue nor smells.
https://www.mieleusa.com/e/miele-ultrap ... 10803670-p
Precise control of dosage.
Excellent Persil detergent (Euro version).
Ease of use is great.
We have no residue nor smells.
Last edited by Bogle7 on Sun Apr 25, 2021 9:51 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Old fart who does three index stock funds, baby.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
If you have an HE front loader, then use powdered.
Liquid or pod liquid leave residue. It causes smells. Powdered stopped that.
Liquid or pod liquid leave residue. It causes smells. Powdered stopped that.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Convenience and according to CR are worse:
https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/lau ... /index.htm
Liquid detergents remain the most widely sold type, and while pods are convenient to use, eliminating the need to measure, even the best pods, also known as packs, can’t match the cleaning power of CR’s top-rated liquid detergents. Some pods are more expensive per load, too. Powders? Sales have dissolved, and few brands are on store shelves.
-
- Posts: 1537
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2018 5:53 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I bought Tide pods when sending my children off to college, thinking it had to be easier than lugging the bottle of Tide down and then back up a few flights of stairs. Each one told me they didn't like the pods b/c they left residue on their clothing. I have no idea if the issue was faulty washing machines or one of them overloading the washing machine, but they returned to school with small bottles of Tide. I have never tried them at home so cannot comment.
I do, however, use the little packets of Cascade and now that someone upthread mentioned needing less for lightly soiled dishes, I may have to buy liquid. I use FAR less laundry detergent than suggested.
I do, however, use the little packets of Cascade and now that someone upthread mentioned needing less for lightly soiled dishes, I may have to buy liquid. I use FAR less laundry detergent than suggested.
-
- Posts: 2569
- Joined: Mon Aug 12, 2019 9:06 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I think it depends on your washing machine and how diligent you are at reading the labels on your laundry detergent.
I use to use liquid - because, being single, sometimes I do small loads and sometimes I do large loads - and I wanted some control over the amount "soap" I was adding. This got frustrating because the liquid detergents kept changing how much to put in per load AND would change the measuring cap. The last bottle of liquid detergent I bought I could barely see the "marks" for small, medium, large, loads on the cap - I tried using a sharpie to mark it - but that became a mess.
And then I bought an HE top loader washer - that had it's own recommendations for how much "soap" to use and recommended using "pods" or no more than 2 TBLS of liquid detergent per load. I don't want to have to measure 2 TBLS of liquid (and I HATE having to figure out how to use a new bottle of detergent - so the pods are easiest and most convenient and do the job. )
I tend to use one pod (I use All clear - cause tide makes me itchy and I don't like the linger fragrances from other detergents) per load - and I no longer do "small loads" if I can avoid it.
Don't get me started on Fabric Softener. I hate that stuff.
Only you can answer your question - after you consider the washer you are using and then reading the label on your detergent.
If you are looking for "cleaning power" - you may want a detergent with "OXY clean" in it... OR you may want to pretreat any stains with a product - I use a gel stick that's "Oxy clean" or something to that effect. When I had a jug o' detergent - I would just pretreat with a bit of the detergent (and some water). Liquid laundry detergent is an amazing cleaner.
I use to use liquid - because, being single, sometimes I do small loads and sometimes I do large loads - and I wanted some control over the amount "soap" I was adding. This got frustrating because the liquid detergents kept changing how much to put in per load AND would change the measuring cap. The last bottle of liquid detergent I bought I could barely see the "marks" for small, medium, large, loads on the cap - I tried using a sharpie to mark it - but that became a mess.
And then I bought an HE top loader washer - that had it's own recommendations for how much "soap" to use and recommended using "pods" or no more than 2 TBLS of liquid detergent per load. I don't want to have to measure 2 TBLS of liquid (and I HATE having to figure out how to use a new bottle of detergent - so the pods are easiest and most convenient and do the job. )
I tend to use one pod (I use All clear - cause tide makes me itchy and I don't like the linger fragrances from other detergents) per load - and I no longer do "small loads" if I can avoid it.
Don't get me started on Fabric Softener. I hate that stuff.
Only you can answer your question - after you consider the washer you are using and then reading the label on your detergent.
If you are looking for "cleaning power" - you may want a detergent with "OXY clean" in it... OR you may want to pretreat any stains with a product - I use a gel stick that's "Oxy clean" or something to that effect. When I had a jug o' detergent - I would just pretreat with a bit of the detergent (and some water). Liquid laundry detergent is an amazing cleaner.
-
- Posts: 773
- Joined: Wed Jun 30, 2010 4:05 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I have been using Kirkland "pods" from Costco after being a liquid Tide user. The clothes get clean, not a lot of suds. I have even stopped using fabric softener. Occasionally I may use some vinegar instead of fabric softener. I am very pleased with the results. My front loader stays much fresher, no build up from detergent or fabric softener around the rubber door gasket.
I also now use Kirkland dishwasher pods and I am very pleased with them as well. The price is great compared to other brands.
I also now use Kirkland dishwasher pods and I am very pleased with them as well. The price is great compared to other brands.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
We've been using and liking a third option: TruEarth ultra concentrated strips. Thirty-two loads in a package not much bigger than #10 envelope.
(The little strips fully dissolve, and after several months of use the machine's little soap drawer shows no signs of residue.)
Cleaning is as effective as Tide concentrated liquid, and we appreciate the extra shelf space and absence of containers going into the trash.
(The little strips fully dissolve, and after several months of use the machine's little soap drawer shows no signs of residue.)
Cleaning is as effective as Tide concentrated liquid, and we appreciate the extra shelf space and absence of containers going into the trash.
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Wow, people sure do pay a lot for convenience then.
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
I read for large loads, it is suggested that one use 3 packets per load, so that would permit 32 loads per box.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Tue May 11, 2021 5:38 pmIt's subjective. I paid $20 for a 96-pack which would last a year and a half. I'm not going to worry if I paid $10 extra over the course of 18 months.
I wonder if these packets work well in top loaders?
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
My washer is full-size, and I usually just use 1, but I'm not very picky. Mine's a top loader; you just place the pod at the bottom before placing clothes that's all.DTalos wrote: ↑Tue May 11, 2021 5:59 pmI read for large loads, it is suggested that one use 3 packets per load, so that would permit 32 loads per box.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Tue May 11, 2021 5:38 pmIt's subjective. I paid $20 for a 96-pack which would last a year and a half. I'm not going to worry if I paid $10 extra over the course of 18 months.
I wonder if these packets work well in top loaders?
-
- Posts: 3527
- Joined: Sat Mar 04, 2017 4:28 pm
- Location: Western Washington
Re: Laundry Detergent Small Packets
They can be, although with high efficiency washers now being ubiquitous, there is more care about specifying amounts to use, because excess detergent will not get rinsed out effectively in a high efficiency washer.egrets wrote: ↑Sun Apr 25, 2021 6:35 pm Quite some time ago I read that the recommended amounts of dishwasher and washing machine detergents were about 2-3 times more than necessary, so I have been using less since then with good results. With the packets, you don't have that choice unless you save half in a dish or something.
Regardless, if what you're doing works for your laundry, that's what matters.