Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
My current hard wired smoke alarms are more than 10 years old and I plan to replace them all. I am looking for recommendations for good quality long lasting alarms. I would prefer if they are both smoke and carbon mono oxide alarms.
I am assuming that this would be a easy job consisting of disconnecting and connecting the wires and screwing the base plate into the wall.
I am seeing this on Amazon : First Alert BRK SC9120B Hardwired Smoke and Carbon Monoxide (CO) Detector with Battery Backup
https://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-SC91 ... publish-20
I am assuming that this would be a easy job consisting of disconnecting and connecting the wires and screwing the base plate into the wall.
I am seeing this on Amazon : First Alert BRK SC9120B Hardwired Smoke and Carbon Monoxide (CO) Detector with Battery Backup
https://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-SC91 ... publish-20
Ram
- jabberwockOG
- Posts: 3087
- Joined: Thu May 28, 2015 7:23 am
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
For CO detectors, I think you'd be fine with just one or two CO detector per level of your house depending on house size.
There are two types of smoke/fire detectors, 1) ionization and 2) photoelectric. Instead of relying on just one type of detector for smoke/fire, I strongly suggest getting a mix of both types, installed at the usual appropriate locations, for each level of the house. One type is a “fast flame” fire detector, the other type is for smoldering fires. ... In tests, ionization alarms will typically respond about 30 to 90 seconds faster to “fast-flame” fires than photoelectric smoke alarms. However, in smoldering fires ionization alarms respond an average of 15 to 50 minutes slower than photoelectric alarms. There are also some more expensive smoke/fire detectors that have both detection technologies in each detector.
Just a few seconds reaction time can mean the difference between life and death in a house fire.
There are two types of smoke/fire detectors, 1) ionization and 2) photoelectric. Instead of relying on just one type of detector for smoke/fire, I strongly suggest getting a mix of both types, installed at the usual appropriate locations, for each level of the house. One type is a “fast flame” fire detector, the other type is for smoldering fires. ... In tests, ionization alarms will typically respond about 30 to 90 seconds faster to “fast-flame” fires than photoelectric smoke alarms. However, in smoldering fires ionization alarms respond an average of 15 to 50 minutes slower than photoelectric alarms. There are also some more expensive smoke/fire detectors that have both detection technologies in each detector.
Just a few seconds reaction time can mean the difference between life and death in a house fire.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Last I looked, CO detectors are best located closer to the floor and there are some long lasting models available that plug into an electrical outlet. We have one in each bedroom.
For smoke detectors, the dual sensor types seem best. Hardwired is nice so one doesn't need to replace many 9V batteries every year.
For smoke detectors, the dual sensor types seem best. Hardwired is nice so one doesn't need to replace many 9V batteries every year.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Disagree on both points. Yes, they make plug in CO monitors which can be plugged into a low wall outlet. But a quick google shows that ideally they'll be mounted 5+ feet from the floor and close to any possible CO source.graeme wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:05 pm Last I looked, CO detectors are best located closer to the floor and there are some long lasting models available that plug into an electrical outlet. We have one in each bedroom.
For smoke detectors, the dual sensor types seem best. Hardwired is nice so one doesn't need to replace many 9V batteries every year.
Also, easier (and recommended?) to change batteries once a year. Can they last longer that one year? Sure, in most cases they will. But it's been my experience, the weak battery chirp always happens at 2 am in the morning.....I'd much rather change the battery as a preventive measure once a year than be awakened from a deep sleep and have to find the step stool to reach the cathedral ceiling to turn off the chirp......chirps........chirp.
- AllMostThere
- Posts: 886
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2016 1:04 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I purchased the Kidde product from Amazon. In bedrooms I used "Kidde i4618 Firex Hardwire Ionization Smoke Detector with Battery Backup" and in the main hallway I used "Kidde KN-COSM-IBA Hardwire Combination Carbon Monoxide and Smoke Alarm with Battery Backup and Voice Warning". These were different brand than those being replaced, so I had to the use the Kidde quick connector to main power. Very easy swap out of the connectors and Smoke/CO units, just couple of wire nuts for the hot, neutral and ground. Just be sure to turn the breaker OFF. No special tools and maybe 15 minutes each taking my time.
It is not about how much you make; it is about how much you keep and how well you invest it. - Author Unknown |
Dream as if you’ll live forever. Live as if you’ll die today. - Author James Dean
- RickBoglehead
- Posts: 7877
- Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2018 8:10 am
- Location: In a house
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Get hardwired with battery backup.
Batteries are now ten years on many.
First Alert BRK 3120B is both ionization and photoelectric, hard wired, and has ten year battery backup.
Batteries are now ten years on many.
First Alert BRK 3120B is both ionization and photoelectric, hard wired, and has ten year battery backup.
Avid user of forums on variety of interests-financial, home brewing, F-150, EV, home repair, etc. Enjoy learning & passing on knowledge. It's PRINCIPAL, not PRINCIPLE. I ADVISE you to seek ADVICE.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I loaded up on Nest Protect smoke alarms last year as part of a Black Friday $75ea sale. https://store.google.com/us/product/nes ... s?hl=en-US
Combo ionization & photoelectric smoke sensor
Humidity sensor to apply logic to prevent steam from triggering the alarm
CO sensor included
These offer a bunch of nice features, like you can turn them into motion-sensing night lights. The alarm triggers in stages, starting with voice warnings at low levels of CO / smoke, and clearly identifies via voice which detector sourced the alarm. You also get push notifications on your phone when the alarm goes off, and the ability to silence the alert using the app.
Battery health and a bunch of other self checks run constantly, and it does an alarm speaker test once a month. If the battery runs low on one of the units, you’ll know exactly which one it is via the push notification — not just a random chirp at 2am.
Combo ionization & photoelectric smoke sensor
Humidity sensor to apply logic to prevent steam from triggering the alarm
CO sensor included
These offer a bunch of nice features, like you can turn them into motion-sensing night lights. The alarm triggers in stages, starting with voice warnings at low levels of CO / smoke, and clearly identifies via voice which detector sourced the alarm. You also get push notifications on your phone when the alarm goes off, and the ability to silence the alert using the app.
Battery health and a bunch of other self checks run constantly, and it does an alarm speaker test once a month. If the battery runs low on one of the units, you’ll know exactly which one it is via the push notification — not just a random chirp at 2am.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
+1 Since they are quite pricey, it would have been too expensive to replace 7 hardwired units. We compromised by putting a single Nest protect per floor in addition to the hardwired First Alert ones in each bedroom and hallway. That way, we still get alerts on our phone if we are out of the house when the alarm goes off.SpaethCo wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:48 pm I loaded up on Nest Protect smoke alarms last year as part of a Black Friday $75ea sale. https://store.google.com/us/product/nes ... s?hl=en-US
Combo ionization & photoelectric smoke sensor
Humidity sensor to apply logic to prevent steam from triggering the alarm
CO sensor included
These offer a bunch of nice features, like you can turn them into motion-sensing night lights. The alarm triggers in stages, starting with voice warnings at low levels of CO / smoke, and clearly identifies via voice which detector sourced the alarm. You also get push notifications on your phone when the alarm goes off, and the ability to silence the alert using the app.
Battery health and a bunch of other self checks run constantly, and it does an alarm speaker test once a month. If the battery runs low on one of the units, you’ll know exactly which one it is via the push notification — not just a random chirp at 2am.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Check with your local fire department first to see what local regulations might apply.
When we sold our home earlier this year, a fire department inspection was required. Based on the age of our home, we needed two alarms that were hardwired, battery backup, interconnected, photoelectric, and talking. We also needed both smoke and CO.
We selected these: https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B002UQW8OS
They were simple to install, replacing the out of date alarms. And they were reasonably priced.
This isn't just my wallet. It's an organizer, a memory and an old friend.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
In Maryland, you are now required to replace smoke detectors with ten year batteries.
At least a couple of counties in Maryland have fire departments who provide free smoke detectors. Mine does for folks over 60 or so.
At least a couple of counties in Maryland have fire departments who provide free smoke detectors. Mine does for folks over 60 or so.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I like this option. Will put one/floor.SpaethCo wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:48 pm I loaded up on Nest Protect smoke alarms last year as part of a Black Friday $75ea sale. https://store.google.com/us/product/nes ... s?hl=en-US
Combo ionization & photoelectric smoke sensor
Humidity sensor to apply logic to prevent steam from triggering the alarm
CO sensor included
These offer a bunch of nice features, like you can turn them into motion-sensing night lights. The alarm triggers in stages, starting with voice warnings at low levels of CO / smoke, and clearly identifies via voice which detector sourced the alarm. You also get push notifications on your phone when the alarm goes off, and the ability to silence the alert using the app.
Battery health and a bunch of other self checks run constantly, and it does an alarm speaker test once a month. If the battery runs low on one of the units, you’ll know exactly which one it is via the push notification — not just a random chirp at 2am.
Will wait for black friday sale.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Looks like it is NOT a CO alarm.RickBoglehead wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:39 pm Get hardwired with battery backup.
Batteries are now ten years on many.
First Alert BRK 3120B is both ionization and photoelectric, hard wired, and has ten year battery backup.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I confirmed that CO is lighter than air.graeme wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:05 pm Last I looked, CO detectors are best located closer to the floor and there are some long lasting models available that plug into an electrical outlet. We have one in each bedroom.
For smoke detectors, the dual sensor types seem best. Hardwired is nice so one doesn't need to replace many 9V batteries every year.
The lower placement seems a matter of convenience (existing plug outlets) than scientific necessity.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Thanks. Learnt something new today.Will pay heed to your advice.jabberwockOG wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 5:42 pm For CO detectors, I think you'd be fine with just one or two CO detector per level of your house depending on house size.
There are two types of smoke/fire detectors, 1) ionization and 2) photoelectric. Instead of relying on just one type of detector for smoke/fire, I strongly suggest getting a mix of both types, installed at the usual appropriate locations, for each level of the house. One type is a “fast flame” fire detector, the other type is for smoldering fires. ... In tests, ionization alarms will typically respond about 30 to 90 seconds faster to “fast-flame” fires than photoelectric smoke alarms. However, in smoldering fires ionization alarms respond an average of 15 to 50 minutes slower than photoelectric alarms. There are also some more expensive smoke/fire detectors that have both detection technologies in each detector.
Just a few seconds reaction time can mean the difference between life and death in a house fire.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
+1 on Nest Protect. I have 3, one on each floor, for 4 years now. A great trouble free product. It contains both types of fire/smoke sensors plus a CO sensor. I have wired and the batteries are just for backup. The app manages the battery life and mine are still good.SpaethCo wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:48 pm I loaded up on Nest Protect smoke alarms last year as part of a Black Friday $75ea sale. https://store.google.com/us/product/nes ... s?hl=en-US
Combo ionization & photoelectric smoke sensor
Humidity sensor to apply logic to prevent steam from triggering the alarm
CO sensor included
These offer a bunch of nice features, like you can turn them into motion-sensing night lights. The alarm triggers in stages, starting with voice warnings at low levels of CO / smoke, and clearly identifies via voice which detector sourced the alarm. You also get push notifications on your phone when the alarm goes off, and the ability to silence the alert using the app.
Battery health and a bunch of other self checks run constantly, and it does an alarm speaker test once a month. If the battery runs low on one of the units, you’ll know exactly which one it is via the push notification — not just a random chirp at 2am.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Thanks. These apparantly lack the ionizing method of smoke detection that jabberwok pointed out.JoeRetire wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 8:30 pmCheck with your local fire department first to see what local regulations might apply.
When we sold our home earlier this year, a fire department inspection was required. Based on the age of our home, we needed two alarms that were hardwired, battery backup, interconnected, photoelectric, and talking. We also needed both smoke and CO.
We selected these: https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B002UQW8OS
They were simple to install, replacing the out of date alarms. And they were reasonably priced.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Executive summary:
If cost is not an issue the Nest product combines all 3 technologies in one product.
- ionizing smoke detection
-photoelectric smoke detection
-CO detection
Boglehead addendum: Consider only one/floor of this costlier product and use other additional cheaper products strategically.
Thanks everybody.
If cost is not an issue the Nest product combines all 3 technologies in one product.
- ionizing smoke detection
-photoelectric smoke detection
-CO detection
Boglehead addendum: Consider only one/floor of this costlier product and use other additional cheaper products strategically.
Thanks everybody.
Ram
- TomatoTomahto
- Posts: 17158
- Joined: Mon Apr 11, 2011 1:48 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Re CO: our town requires one not inside each bedroom and no more than 10 feet from the bedroom door. Plug in ones are okay, so that’s what we did. Must have a minimum of one per floor. So, all in, that was 4 CO detectors.
There is no exemption for houses without any fossil fuel combustion. We do have a fireplace. Our garage is detached (so no CO from car exhaust).
There is no exemption for houses without any fossil fuel combustion. We do have a fireplace. Our garage is detached (so no CO from car exhaust).
I get the FI part but not the RE part of FIRE.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
My main point was to get a recommendation from your local fire department. They may or may not agree with jabberwok, requirements.ram wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 1:15 pmThanks. These apparantly lack the ionizing method of smoke detection that jabberwok pointed out.JoeRetire wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 8:30 pmCheck with your local fire department first to see what local regulations might apply.
When we sold our home earlier this year, a fire department inspection was required. Based on the age of our home, we needed two alarms that were hardwired, battery backup, interconnected, photoelectric, and talking. We also needed both smoke and CO.
We selected these: https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B002UQW8OS
They were simple to install, replacing the out of date alarms. And they were reasonably priced.
This isn't just my wallet. It's an organizer, a memory and an old friend.
-
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 6:46 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Our smoke detectors are hard wired. We have one inside and outside each bedroom, 8 in total. One night they all went off at 2 in the morning for about 20 seconds. After checking that there was no smoke or fire we all went back to bed. I wondered which detector set them off. So next day, I read the manual and it said the one setting off the alarm would have a blinking red light and the rest a steady red light. Well, it happened again the next night and I ran around and found the one with the blinking light. Next day, I got a step ladder and detached that detector from its base, and detached the bottom part from the detector. There was a silverfish roaming around the bottom. Problem solved. It happened again a several years later. This is useful information in case it happens to you.
- RickBoglehead
- Posts: 7877
- Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2018 8:10 am
- Location: In a house
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Correct. It is a dual smoke sensor, electric, interconnected, and 10 year battery backup. We have one inside each bedroom, one in each hallway, one in the basement. To have that many CO alarms is unnecessary.ram wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 1:00 pmLooks like it is NOT a CO alarm.RickBoglehead wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:39 pm Get hardwired with battery backup.
Batteries are now ten years on many.
First Alert BRK 3120B is both ionization and photoelectric, hard wired, and has ten year battery backup.
Avid user of forums on variety of interests-financial, home brewing, F-150, EV, home repair, etc. Enjoy learning & passing on knowledge. It's PRINCIPAL, not PRINCIPLE. I ADVISE you to seek ADVICE.
- TomatoTomahto
- Posts: 17158
- Joined: Mon Apr 11, 2011 1:48 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
@testing321, and if you have security monitoring systems, there is a code (in my case *72) to clear the indicators about which detector went off. I learned this during our final fire inspection, where the inspector set off each alarm and wanted me to clear the indicator between tests.
I get the FI part but not the RE part of FIRE.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
You can get the combo CO/smoke alarm and place one on each floor.
For instance, we have ours in the basement, first floor and second floor hallways have the combo CO alarm.
The photo/ionization alarms can go in the bedrooms.
Mid-40’s
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Agree.RickBoglehead wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 3:22 pmCorrect. It is a dual smoke sensor, electric, interconnected, and 10 year battery backup. We have one inside each bedroom, one in each hallway, one in the basement. To have that many CO alarms is unnecessary.ram wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 1:00 pmLooks like it is NOT a CO alarm.RickBoglehead wrote: ↑Sat Nov 09, 2019 6:39 pm Get hardwired with battery backup.
Batteries are now ten years on many.
First Alert BRK 3120B is both ionization and photoelectric, hard wired, and has ten year battery backup.
Ram
-
- Posts: 1071
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2018 10:14 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
When replacing a 10 year old hard wired alarm, it's a good idea to get one which plugs into the same plug, and mounts on the same mounting bracket. Otherwise you might have to remove the mounting bracket and install another one; probably needing different holes in the ceiling. If the plugs are different then you need to install a new plug. If you don't mind doing that, fine; but when I did it, I just called the company to find out which of their options would match both the plugs and the mounting brackets; then chose my desired features from that narrowed list.
Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're NOT out to get you.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
It's actually very easy, and I would not use this as criteria for selecting a replacement detector. You would not need different holes. All of the mounting brackets are designed to attach easily to a standard 1- or 2-gang electrical box, which is what is in your ceiling already. The wiring is connected by wire nuts--just unscrew, replace old wire with new, screw back in. The second time you do this it will take less than 2 minutes.GrowthSeeker wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 5:06 pm When replacing a 10 year old hard wired alarm, it's a good idea to get one which plugs into the same plug, and mounts on the same mounting bracket. Otherwise you might have to remove the mounting bracket and install another one; probably needing different holes in the ceiling. If the plugs are different then you need to install a new plug. If you don't mind doing that, fine; but when I did it, I just called the company to find out which of their options would match both the plugs and the mounting brackets; then chose my desired features from that narrowed list.
I will also add my voice to the chorus on the Nest Protects. I have 7, one in each occupied bedroom, one in the hallway outside the bedrooms, one each in the kitchen, living/dining room, and in the finished basement. 3 are wired and 4 are battery. I just had to replace the batteries in the Master Bedroom one (it takes six lithium AAs) after 5 years because we use the pathlight feature so much. Will be replacing them with the then-current equivalent when they reach the end of their lifespan in a few years.
- jeffyscott
- Posts: 13485
- Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 8:12 am
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I was able to do that once, no need to change mounting bracket or plug. But recently replaced all of ours, which were 10-20 years old (Firex brand) and it was not possible as the designs had changed. One of ours was supposed to have an adapter to fit Firex but couldn't get that to plug in right, so had to change the plug anyway.GrowthSeeker wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2019 5:06 pm When replacing a 10 year old hard wired alarm, it's a good idea to get one which plugs into the same plug, and mounts on the same mounting bracket. Otherwise you might have to remove the mounting bracket and install another one; probably needing different holes in the ceiling. If the plugs are different then you need to install a new plug. If you don't mind doing that, fine; but when I did it, I just called the company to find out which of their options would match both the plugs and the mounting brackets; then chose my desired features from that narrowed list.
We put a photoelectric one by the kitchen as that should be less susceptible to false alarms, based on what I have read. In hall by bedrooms, there are two, so I put one of each type. Basement has one, so we put a dual one there. All were Kidde/Firex bought at Menards and were easy to install, even though I had to change the mounting brackets and plugs. Had a little extra work with the basement one, just due to the way the builder had mounted the power converter on the electrical box 20+ years ago. I had to relocate the converter, due to the somewhat larger diameter of the new detectors.
We have a separate CO detector and did not consider CO/smoke combo units as CR says: Consumer Reports has yet to test a combination detector with both ionization and photoelectric sensors that can capably detect CO, flaming fires, and smoldering fires. Plus I prefer our stand alone CO detector as you can press a button and see the peak reading, even when it is as low as 10 ppm. I like having that, rather than just an alarm that goes off at 50 ppm or whatever.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Question for those with the hardwired Nest Protect systems—how (if at all) will it interact with the non-smart smokes also hardwired into the house? Thinking about replacing two of ours with the Nest (one on each floor) but if that negates the ability to trigger all smokes together, I’ll have to revisit the plan.
KT785
KT785
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Not recommended. See: https://support.google.com/googlenest/a ... 1654?hl=enKT785 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 11, 2019 2:19 pm Question for those with the hardwired Nest Protect systems—how (if at all) will it interact with the non-smart smokes also hardwired into the house? Thinking about replacing two of ours with the Nest (one on each floor) but if that negates the ability to trigger all smokes together, I’ll have to revisit the plan.
KT785
Can I buy a Nest Protect and connect it to my existing smoke and carbon monoxide alarms?
Unfortunately no, but this isn’t unusual. Each company’s smoke and CO alarms use proprietary detection algorithms and interfaces. And therefore there’s no industry standard. If alarms from different companies are connected together, they may not warn you properly in an emergency. The NFPA actually prohibits the connection of alarms from different manufacturers without special testing. To the best of our knowledge, no company sells a combination smoke and CO alarm that is meant to be connected with a different company’s smoke and CO alarm. Some companies even state in their documentation not to connect to a different company’s smoke and CO alarm.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
If memory serves, they use the wiring for power only. They do not communicate with other Nest Protects over the power wiring, nor with other brands of detectors. The Nest Protects form their own wireless mesh network, I believe using the Zigbee protocol, and they can use Wifi as a fallback.KT785 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 11, 2019 2:19 pm Question for those with the hardwired Nest Protect systems—how (if at all) will it interact with the non-smart smokes also hardwired into the house? Thinking about replacing two of ours with the Nest (one on each floor) but if that negates the ability to trigger all smokes together, I’ll have to revisit the plan.
-
- Posts: 1071
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2018 10:14 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
The hard wired ones I had, I think it was Lidde, we’re: if one alarms, they all alarm.
Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're NOT out to get you.
-
- Posts: 171
- Joined: Wed Mar 06, 2019 4:54 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
That's correct re: wiring. Best to replace all at once.lazydavid wrote: ↑Mon Nov 11, 2019 2:26 pmIf memory serves, they use the wiring for power only. They do not communicate with other Nest Protects over the power wiring, nor with other brands of detectors. The Nest Protects form their own wireless mesh network, I believe using the Zigbee protocol, and they can use Wifi as a fallback.KT785 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 11, 2019 2:19 pm Question for those with the hardwired Nest Protect systems—how (if at all) will it interact with the non-smart smokes also hardwired into the house? Thinking about replacing two of ours with the Nest (one on each floor) but if that negates the ability to trigger all smokes together, I’ll have to revisit the plan.
I have several Nests, purchased because I travel fairly frequently. They link to my home security system (Abode) which is also a home automation controller. Over the past year I've had them, no problems. I have in the past come home to ongoing alarm from failed detector.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
This is true, UNLESS they are hardwired, then you can have a hardwired detector with 9V battery backup. In other words, if you replace a battery-powered smoke detector, you have to replace it with a new, sealed battery unit. If you have hardwired detectors, you can replace them with hardwired detectors.
With that said, my house had FireX installed previously, but I replaced everything with Kidde equipment. One combination CO/smoke detector on each floor and smoke detectors in each bedroom. Installation isn’t too difficult - if you can change an electrical outlet, you can change a smoke detector power adapter.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I used these because they are bulk priced and one-for-one replacements for my old ones.
I have separate CO2 detectors.
Last Christmas Eve, a family in my town lost 3 of 5 members because their smoke detectors didn’t work. The father, who should have maintained the detectors, survived and has to live with the reality that his inaction cost his wife and 2 children their lives. Having up-to-date detectors and new batteries is extremely important. Don’t let it slide! Code here requires 1 in each bedroom and 1 in the hall outside each bedroom.
https://www.costco.com/first-alert-hard ... 13054.html
I have separate CO2 detectors.
Last Christmas Eve, a family in my town lost 3 of 5 members because their smoke detectors didn’t work. The father, who should have maintained the detectors, survived and has to live with the reality that his inaction cost his wife and 2 children their lives. Having up-to-date detectors and new batteries is extremely important. Don’t let it slide! Code here requires 1 in each bedroom and 1 in the hall outside each bedroom.
https://www.costco.com/first-alert-hard ... 13054.html
-
- Posts: 63
- Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2018 10:16 am
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Ram, I wish I had posted your question here a few months ago when I had to replace my 8 Smoke and 2 CO alarms. There is a lot of good information posted here. I replaced my FireX alarms with First Alert alarms. The things I learned were:
1) I found that Amazon had the best pricing.
2) The old FireX plugs were not compatible with the First Alert ones but changing the plug just involved unscrewing & screwing wire nuts
3) I replaced the Ionization Smoke Alarm in the Kitchen with a Combo Photoelectric Smoke Alarm & CO Monitor. That cut down false alarms and gave me CO Monitoring on the first floor.
4) Originally I only had Ionization Smoke Alarms, so this time, I put one Dual Sensor Smoke Alarm on each floor of my house.
5) Smoke Alarms are only suppose to be reliable for 10 years so the replacements all have batteries that last 10 years.
6) Ionization Smoke Alarms have a tiny amount of radioactive material
7) Kidde bought FireX and are suppose to accept FireX Ionization alarms for recycling. I haven't had much luck with that.
1) I found that Amazon had the best pricing.
2) The old FireX plugs were not compatible with the First Alert ones but changing the plug just involved unscrewing & screwing wire nuts
3) I replaced the Ionization Smoke Alarm in the Kitchen with a Combo Photoelectric Smoke Alarm & CO Monitor. That cut down false alarms and gave me CO Monitoring on the first floor.
4) Originally I only had Ionization Smoke Alarms, so this time, I put one Dual Sensor Smoke Alarm on each floor of my house.
5) Smoke Alarms are only suppose to be reliable for 10 years so the replacements all have batteries that last 10 years.
6) Ionization Smoke Alarms have a tiny amount of radioactive material
7) Kidde bought FireX and are suppose to accept FireX Ionization alarms for recycling. I haven't had much luck with that.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I got 3 Nest combo alarms (both methods of fire detection and CO detection). Very happy with them. Fitting was easy.
They are hardwired and have a 10 yr backup battery.
Target had a sale at $60 each. Costco was 170 for a pack of 2 and Amazon was 100 each.
Thanks everybody.
They are hardwired and have a 10 yr backup battery.
Target had a sale at $60 each. Costco was 170 for a pack of 2 and Amazon was 100 each.
Thanks everybody.
Ram
-
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Tue Jan 17, 2017 7:46 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Are you sure about the battery? I put a hardwired Nest in a couple of months ago, and it had 3 AA Lithium batteries that they said would last three years.
- southerndoc
- Posts: 1266
- Joined: Wed Apr 22, 2009 7:07 pm
- Location: Atlanta
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Some states (California one of them) require a 10-year battery.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I don't recall reading anything about a 10-year battery, which would be odd given that the detector itself--at least for the first-gen units--has only a 7-year life.michaelingp wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 9:02 pm Are you sure about the battery? I put a hardwired Nest in a couple of months ago, and it had 3 AA Lithium batteries that they said would last three years.
From a real-world perspective, my first Nest Protect is a wired unit a little over 6 years old, and its backup batteries are still going strong. But I've recently replaced the batteries in two of my non-hardwired ones (which use 6 lithium AAs rather than 3) at about the 5-year mark because the app let me know that they only had a few months of life left.
I guess that's a long-winded way of saying there's no way the batteries in your wired detector will only last 3 years.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
It is not a ten-year life when the batteries are in use. It is a 10 year shelf life. Battery manufacturers cannot certify how much draw your smoke alarm is putting on the battery and I doubt they will last 10 years.southerndoc wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 11:21 pm Some states (California one of them) require a 10-year battery.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Newer units often have non-replaceable 10 year batterires ... good for 10 years and no wiring needed.Gort wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2019 10:36 amIt is not a ten-year life when the batteries are in use. It is a 10 year shelf life. Battery manufacturers cannot certify how much draw your smoke alarm is putting on the battery and I doubt they will last 10 years.southerndoc wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 11:21 pm Some states (California one of them) require a 10-year battery.
https://www.amazon.com/Combination-Mono ... s9dHJ1ZQ==
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
The newer sealed battery smoke alarms are intended to last ten years even when in operation (i.e. powered). At least, that's how the law is intended to operate.Gort wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2019 10:36 amIt is not a ten-year life when the batteries are in use. It is a 10 year shelf life. Battery manufacturers cannot certify how much draw your smoke alarm is putting on the battery and I doubt they will last 10 years.southerndoc wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 11:21 pm Some states (California one of them) require a 10-year battery.
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-release ... 05751.html
California Senate Bill 745 requires that all solely battery-operated smoke alarms and combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms sold and installed in California must contain a non-replaceable, non-removable battery that is capable of powering the smoke alarm for a minimum of 10 years.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Thanks for the info. Good to know.mervinj7 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2019 11:22 amThe newer sealed battery smoke alarms are intended to last ten years even when in operation (i.e. powered). At least, that's how the law is intended to operate.Gort wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2019 10:36 amIt is not a ten-year life when the batteries are in use. It is a 10 year shelf life. Battery manufacturers cannot certify how much draw your smoke alarm is putting on the battery and I doubt they will last 10 years.southerndoc wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 11:21 pm Some states (California one of them) require a 10-year battery.
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-release ... 05751.html
California Senate Bill 745 requires that all solely battery-operated smoke alarms and combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms sold and installed in California must contain a non-replaceable, non-removable battery that is capable of powering the smoke alarm for a minimum of 10 years.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
I wanted to get NEST alarms - however since I have 8 alarms that I had to replace - I couldn't stomach buying 8 NEST. You cannot mix and match NEST w/o other non NEST alarms - at least if you want to stay compliant.
I went with all First Alert - couple combo fire/mono - kitchen area and main hallway.
I went with all First Alert - couple combo fire/mono - kitchen area and main hallway.
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Couple other important points I don't see mentioned:
1) You typically get small discount on homeowners insurance for having an alarm with central monitoring for fire as well as burglary. 'Self monitoring' generally is not enough.
2) Most DIY wireless alarm systems like Ring or Abode, probably SimpliSafe too, DON'T have their own smoke/fire detectors. All the regulatory approvals, UL, EPA (ionizing types have a miniscule bit of a radioactive isotope, Americium IIRC) are prohibitive. INSTEAD, Ring and Abode (again unsure of SimpliSafe) have a wireless listener module you mount next to your conventional detectors. They are tripped by the audio, similar to a glass break sensor, but listen for s very specific tone pattern put out by smoke detectors to limit false alarms.
See
https://goabode.com/security-devices/ac ... rm-monitor
and
https://shop.ring.com/products/alarm-smoke-co-listener
3) On some of the hardwired smoke alarms they also still have a backup battery you can install. Highly recommended. Hate to have a fire but no alarm because power went out after a bad surge.
1) You typically get small discount on homeowners insurance for having an alarm with central monitoring for fire as well as burglary. 'Self monitoring' generally is not enough.
2) Most DIY wireless alarm systems like Ring or Abode, probably SimpliSafe too, DON'T have their own smoke/fire detectors. All the regulatory approvals, UL, EPA (ionizing types have a miniscule bit of a radioactive isotope, Americium IIRC) are prohibitive. INSTEAD, Ring and Abode (again unsure of SimpliSafe) have a wireless listener module you mount next to your conventional detectors. They are tripped by the audio, similar to a glass break sensor, but listen for s very specific tone pattern put out by smoke detectors to limit false alarms.
See
https://goabode.com/security-devices/ac ... rm-monitor
and
https://shop.ring.com/products/alarm-smoke-co-listener
3) On some of the hardwired smoke alarms they also still have a backup battery you can install. Highly recommended. Hate to have a fire but no alarm because power went out after a bad surge.
-
- Posts: 653
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 12:51 pm
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
The UL standard for smoke alarms is getting updated in May 2020. I would consider holding off until you get one that meets the new standard and has received some reviews. A few compliant detectors have been released, but not a lot of reviews on them. I don't think the Nest meets the new standard either so maybe wait until they push out a gen 3 model.
Edit to add link: https://www.ul.com/news/new-smoke-alarm ... oming-soon
Edit to add link: https://www.ul.com/news/new-smoke-alarm ... oming-soon
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
Find out what local fire code requires first, then find appropriate alarms. The physical work to change them is minimal, assuming you have basic skills and don't have vertigo.
Many jurisdictions have specific requirements for CO detection. It is a heavy gas, and you are much better off with lower detectors -- especially if you have bedrooms on the first floor.
Many jurisdictions have specific requirements for CO detection. It is a heavy gas, and you are much better off with lower detectors -- especially if you have bedrooms on the first floor.
“Adapt what is useful, reject what is useless, and add what is specifically your own.” ― Bruce Lee
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
No. You may be correct.michaelingp wrote: ↑Sun Dec 15, 2019 9:02 pmAre you sure about the battery? I put a hardwired Nest in a couple of months ago, and it had 3 AA Lithium batteries that they said would last three years.
The official version is :
BACKUP BATTERY
3 AA Energizer® Ultimate Lithium batteries (L91).
Nest Protect will let you know its backup
batteries are getting low before they need to
be replaced. Instead of lighting up green during
Nightly Promise, it’ll glow yellow. Once you
press the Nest button, Nest Protect will say,
“The battery is low. Replace it soon.”
In case of power outage, Nest Protect uses
long-life backup lithium batteries designed to
last multiple years of operation. Battery life
depends on usage.
Ram
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
This is incorrect. CO is slightly lighter than air. Air has a molecular weight of 28.966, while CO is 28.011. CO mixes very easily with air.
(emphasis mine)National Fire Protection Association Standard NFPA 720-2009 wrote:The location for effective performance is not generally dependent on mounting height. The density of carbon monoxide is similar to that of air at room temperature, and carbon monoxide generally mixes readily with air.
The UL standard 2034 for Single and Multiple Station Carbon Monoxide Alarms does not include any requirements or tests for mounting at specific heights. The NFPA says CO alarms "shall be located on the wall, ceiling or other location as specify in the installation instructions that come with the unit."
The reason CO detectors were traditionally mounted low is because the early dedicated ones had to be plugged into a wall outlet. Guess where those are in most people's homes?
Bottom line: all other factors being equal, mounting height makes no difference whatsoever with regard to CO detection.
- RickBoglehead
- Posts: 7877
- Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2018 8:10 am
- Location: In a house
Re: Hard Wired smoke alarms. Recommendations.
SimpliSafe has its own battery powered wireless detectors. These do not meet the requirements for having wired smoke detectors. I updated my wired smoke detectors (with battery backup) as they were over 10 years old, AND I had wireless, battery powered, smoke detectors with my older alarm system, and now with my new SimpliSafe system.rj342 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2019 12:09 pm Couple other important points I don't see mentioned:
1) You typically get small discount on homeowners insurance for having an alarm with central monitoring for fire as well as burglary. 'Self monitoring' generally is not enough.
2) Most DIY wireless alarm systems like Ring or Abode, probably SimpliSafe too, DON'T have their own smoke/fire detectors. All the regulatory approvals, UL, EPA (ionizing types have a miniscule bit of a radioactive isotope, Americium IIRC) are prohibitive. INSTEAD, Ring and Abode (again unsure of SimpliSafe) have a wireless listener module you mount next to your conventional detectors. They are tripped by the audio, similar to a glass break sensor, but listen for s very specific tone pattern put out by smoke detectors to limit false alarms.
See
https://goabode.com/security-devices/ac ... rm-monitor
and
https://shop.ring.com/products/alarm-smoke-co-listener
3) On some of the hardwired smoke alarms they also still have a backup battery you can install. Highly recommended. Hate to have a fire but no alarm because power went out after a bad surge.
Avid user of forums on variety of interests-financial, home brewing, F-150, EV, home repair, etc. Enjoy learning & passing on knowledge. It's PRINCIPAL, not PRINCIPLE. I ADVISE you to seek ADVICE.