Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
ETA: Below was specific to the still uninvested money in your Roth IRA.
I'll repeat my advice from earlier. The best thing you can do is decide when to get your money in, schedule it, and quit stressing about it.
If it were me, I'd lump sum today and be invested. Clearly that doesn't work for you, and that's completely OK.
If you are more comfortable DCA, then schedule it.
Pick your time horizon (let's say 6 months) and your interval (who knows, maybe you'd feel better doing daily investments so you are guaranteed to get all the days at the lowest price possible). Divide the amount you have left to invest by the above, and schedule the investment(s) accordingly.
You want this to become a routine, non-emotional, and non-thought provoking activity. You invest because you must.*
*Arguably with your existing assets, high income and low expenses, plus very strong pensions/social security, and potentially a sizable inheritance, you may not actually "need" to invest... You'll likely be set for life under most scenarios. But you still arguably should invest as inflation is going to erode your existing assets, you can't bank on an inheritance, and while you won't ever be "poor" with your pension and social security, without being invested in the market you could see a marked decrease in your quality of life (aka disposable income).
I'll repeat my advice from earlier. The best thing you can do is decide when to get your money in, schedule it, and quit stressing about it.
If it were me, I'd lump sum today and be invested. Clearly that doesn't work for you, and that's completely OK.
If you are more comfortable DCA, then schedule it.
Pick your time horizon (let's say 6 months) and your interval (who knows, maybe you'd feel better doing daily investments so you are guaranteed to get all the days at the lowest price possible). Divide the amount you have left to invest by the above, and schedule the investment(s) accordingly.
You want this to become a routine, non-emotional, and non-thought provoking activity. You invest because you must.*
*Arguably with your existing assets, high income and low expenses, plus very strong pensions/social security, and potentially a sizable inheritance, you may not actually "need" to invest... You'll likely be set for life under most scenarios. But you still arguably should invest as inflation is going to erode your existing assets, you can't bank on an inheritance, and while you won't ever be "poor" with your pension and social security, without being invested in the market you could see a marked decrease in your quality of life (aka disposable income).
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I'd work backwards...AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:38 pm I didn’t even know what FSKAX was in January 2021, not did I have an IRA or taxable to invest. So I made no judgments on its price at that time. I opened my TD account in April and Fidelity in October. But I see your point.
So since I’m wading into this w my IRA and taxable, what would you suggest for my $650k in cash? I need 5 yrs of expenses (say $50kx5=$250k to be generous) to sleep well at night, so arguably I could invest $400k this very year.
I mean, I’m not going to, but maybe 50-75k I could realistically do. Plus my maxed 401k & catch upandRoth IRA andcatch up and match and ibonds…
26k 401
10k ibonds
7k Roth IRA
Match
86k savings
50-75k taxable
Might work out well!
If your target AA is 30/70, and once you get your Roth, 401k, etc. invested, how much of your "cash" needs to be invested in stocks to reach your target AA?
Presumably, your 30/70 is already more than your 5 years expense.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I have to check my totals on 1/31 and see what’s left to do. So far I’ve just tinkered. I’ll post my 1/31 numbers but yeah probably more like 200k would have to go in.SnowBog wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:45 pmI'd work backwards...AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:38 pm I didn’t even know what FSKAX was in January 2021, not did I have an IRA or taxable to invest. So I made no judgments on its price at that time. I opened my TD account in April and Fidelity in October. But I see your point.
So since I’m wading into this w my IRA and taxable, what would you suggest for my $650k in cash? I need 5 yrs of expenses (say $50kx5=$250k to be generous) to sleep well at night, so arguably I could invest $400k this very year.
I mean, I’m not going to, but maybe 50-75k I could realistically do. Plus my maxed 401k & catch upandRoth IRA andcatch up and match and ibonds…
26k 401
10k ibonds
7k Roth IRA
Match
86k savings
50-75k taxable
Might work out well!
If your target AA is 30/70, and once you get your Roth, 401k, etc. invested, how much of your "cash" needs to be invested in stocks to reach your target AA?
Presumably, your 30/70 is already more than your 5 years expense.
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
That doesn't make sense.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:48 pmI have to check my totals on 1/31 and see what’s left to do. So far I’ve just tinkered. I’ll post my 1/31 numbers but yeah probably more like 200k would have to go in.SnowBog wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:45 pmI'd work backwards...AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 6:38 pm I didn’t even know what FSKAX was in January 2021, not did I have an IRA or taxable to invest. So I made no judgments on its price at that time. I opened my TD account in April and Fidelity in October. But I see your point.
So since I’m wading into this w my IRA and taxable, what would you suggest for my $650k in cash? I need 5 yrs of expenses (say $50kx5=$250k to be generous) to sleep well at night, so arguably I could invest $400k this very year.
I mean, I’m not going to, but maybe 50-75k I could realistically do. Plus my maxed 401k & catch upandRoth IRA andcatch up and match and ibonds…
26k 401
10k ibonds
7k Roth IRA
Match
86k savings
50-75k taxable
Might work out well!
If your target AA is 30/70, and once you get your Roth, 401k, etc. invested, how much of your "cash" needs to be invested in stocks to reach your target AA?
Presumably, your 30/70 is already more than your 5 years expense.
You said your AA is 1.2M give or take (1.8M NW minus 1/3 being your property).
Going 30/70 means 360K (equities) / 840K (fixed income, *including* cash).
You should really double check if you have 200K cash to invest in here.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I need my current numbers but my equity position in my 401k is approximately only 120k, plus now 5k in FSKAX. The rest is 650 cash, plus bonds etc.
So 200k is about right that I would need to add.
I can’t imagine putting in more than 50-75 this year from my cash, over and above my IRA and 401k which are going partly into equities.
So 200k is about right that I would need to add.
I can’t imagine putting in more than 50-75 this year from my cash, over and above my IRA and 401k which are going partly into equities.
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Gotcha, in that case then yeah, 200K sounds about right.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:01 pm I need my current numbers but my equity position in my 401k is approximately only 120k, plus now 5k in FSKAX. The rest is 650 cash, plus bonds etc.
So 200k is about right that I would need to add.
I can’t imagine putting in more than 50-75 this year from my cash, over and above my IRA and 401k which are going partly into equities.
It is recommended to deploy within 6~12 months. My recommendation is 20K/mo *regardless* of market conditions.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Wow, if I ever get to the point where I’m comfortable investing 20k a month… I’ll really know I’m not in Kansas anymore. This place continues to expand my view of what is possible. Which of course is why I’m here, making an effort to learn.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:07 pmGotcha, in that case then yeah, 200K sounds about right.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:01 pm I need my current numbers but my equity position in my 401k is approximately only 120k, plus now 5k in FSKAX. The rest is 650 cash, plus bonds etc.
So 200k is about right that I would need to add.
I can’t imagine putting in more than 50-75 this year from my cash, over and above my IRA and 401k which are going partly into equities.
It is recommended to deploy within 6~12 months. My recommendation is 20K/mo *regardless* of market conditions.
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
That's the math though. I mean...if you see upthread, SnowBog is actually suggesting lump sum, i.e. 200K all at once tomorrow. 20K/mo is actually on the slower side, but an acceptable pace for DCAing.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:18 pm Wow, if I ever get to the point where I’m comfortable investing 20k a month… I’ll really know I’m not in Kansas anymore. This place continues to expand my view of what is possible. Which of course is why I’m here, making an effort to learn.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step in and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”Marseille07 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:28 pmThat's the math though. I mean...if you see upthread, SnowBog is actually suggesting lump sum, i.e. 200K all at once tomorrow. 20K/mo is actually on the slower side, but an acceptable pace for DCAing.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:18 pm Wow, if I ever get to the point where I’m comfortable investing 20k a month… I’ll really know I’m not in Kansas anymore. This place continues to expand my view of what is possible. Which of course is why I’m here, making an effort to learn.
I’m over the income and net worth limits for an accredited investor but what if I weren’t? My grandkid could come over and “help” me invest my life savings in Tesla in a single day?
Last edited by AnnetteLouisan on Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- retired@50
- Posts: 12830
- Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2019 2:36 pm
- Location: Living in the U.S.A.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Of course it's allowed. I've moved over $500,000 in a single day for my father in law at Vanguard. It's your money after all.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
Regards,
Last edited by retired@50 on Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.
If liberty means anything at all it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear. -George Orwell
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Imo if you struggle to invest 20K/mo for 10 months, 30/70 is probably too aggressive. And that's OK, people have different levels of risk tolerance.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
I’m over the income and net worth limits for an accredited investor but what if I weren’t? My grandkid could come over and “help” me invest my life savings in Tesla in a single day?
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Well, 30/70 is a target. My thought was to mosey on toward it gradually.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:42 pmImo if you struggle to invest 20K/mo for 10 months, 30/70 is probably too aggressive. And that's OK, people have different levels of risk tolerance.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
I’m over the income and net worth limits for an accredited investor but what if I weren’t? My grandkid could come over and “help” me invest my life savings in Tesla in a single day?
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
As SnowBog said, the standard here is to lump sum. DCAing over 6~12 months is on the slower side, but it is acceptable if it makes you feel comfortable.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:43 pmWell, 30/70 is a target. My thought was to mosey on toward it gradually.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:42 pmImo if you struggle to invest 20K/mo for 10 months, 30/70 is probably too aggressive. And that's OK, people have different levels of risk tolerance.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
I’m over the income and net worth limits for an accredited investor but what if I weren’t? My grandkid could come over and “help” me invest my life savings in Tesla in a single day?
Anything longer isn't recommended because your cash is sitting on the sidelines for too long.
Some people suggest a hybrid approach where you invest 100K tomorrow then another 100K over 6~12 months.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
For clarity, my lump sum comment was on whatever balance remains of the $10,500 sitting in Roth to be invested. Of which, $3,500 has been sitting there in cash since the account was funded late last year.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:28 pmThat's the math though. I mean...if you see upthread, SnowBog is actually suggesting lump sum, i.e. 200K all at once tomorrow. 20K/mo is actually on the slower side, but an acceptable pace for DCAing.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:18 pm Wow, if I ever get to the point where I’m comfortable investing 20k a month… I’ll really know I’m not in Kansas anymore. This place continues to expand my view of what is possible. Which of course is why I’m here, making an effort to learn.
I believe OP has already decided to go 100% in the Roth with FSKAX. So it's simply a matter of pulling the trigger.
Frankly, I'd be happy for them regardless of what trigger they pull, be it lump sum or DCA (ideally with a scheduled investment so they don't forget, delay, etc. further).
But I'm 100% supportive of your general recommendation to set a schedule, no longer than by end of year, to DCA the rest of whatever investments are required to reach AA. If they aren't comfortable doing that, then they need to rethink their AA.
Respectfully, while I understand, I think you are looking at this wrong... This isn't about "investing $20k a month"...AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:18 pm Wow, if I ever get to the point where I’m comfortable investing 20k a month…
If your target AA is 30/70, then you take the steps necessary to get to your target AA. And you should do so ASAP. If it takes you years to get to your AA, then your AA wasn't set correctly. Ultimately, if you aren't comfortable - or comfortable yet - at 30/70, then be honest with yourself (and us).
If you are comfortable with 30/70, but you'd rather DCA, then set a time line to get there. Personally I think 6 - 12 months is a reasonable time frame. The rest is simple math and execution. If you have $200k in cash that needs to be invested to reach your AA, and you do so over 10 months, then yep that's $20k/month. But that's not permanent, you aren't going to do that going forward. That's simply your one-time path to get to your AA.
Going forward, you'll likely maintain your AA via how you invest future money. Assuming stocks grow quicker than bonds, with a 30/70 AA the bulk of future investments will stay in fixed income. (My AA is 60/40, but my bonds get far more than 40% of "new money" to keep up.)
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
So you’re saying it’s really just repositioning the funds more advantageously in a sense, not entirely like investing. Just moving things I already own into a better framework.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Exactly!AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 9:05 pm So you’re saying it’s really just repositioning the funds more advantageously in a sense, not entirely like investing. Just moving things I already own into a better framework.
And to expand...
If 30/70 is the right AA for you, and these are long term investments, and you believe that over the long term the market will go up (even if it's a bumpy ride along the way), then there is no cheaper time than right now to buy.
Sure, we could have a crash tomorrow, or next month, or in a year... But no one can predict when, how big, etc. And in the long term, the crash will be a blip anyway. You are investing for the future.
Last edited by SnowBog on Wed Jan 19, 2022 9:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
My brother calls investing similar to adjusting the sails on a big Spanish galleon. The more sails you have out, the more wind you catch… he has no qualms about investing and got started in 2009.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Not sure what to do with this...AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 9:10 pm My brother calls investing similar to adjusting the sails on a big Spanish galleon. The more sails you have out, the more wind you catch… he has no qualms about investing and got started in 2009.
If he's using low cost index funds, I'd agree with him. By owning the entire market, I'm betting on people (and businesses) to do what's in their nature. Over the long term, that's a comfortable place to be. (And why I'm not overly price sensitive for long term investing.)
But if he's picking individual stocks, and the analogy is picking more individual stocks... Well, then I'd be very worried about what happens when the wind stops...
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
About half of what he has are low cost index funds. The rest are individual stocks in well known sectors. No crypto or NFTs. He does pretty well with it.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Just got my trade confirmation from Fidelity- my order executed at 126.3! Even better than the 127 I thought I was buying at! Kind of nice! My last purchase was at 133.
I get that in the scheme of things price shouldn’t matter much but there is a small satisfaction in getting more fund shares than one would have two weeks ago for the same price. In most other contexts of life price is a critical factor.
I get that in the scheme of things price shouldn’t matter much but there is a small satisfaction in getting more fund shares than one would have two weeks ago for the same price. In most other contexts of life price is a critical factor.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
It's always nice to buy at a lower price!AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 6:41 am ... there is a small satisfaction in getting more fund shares than one would have two weeks ago for the same price. In most other contexts of life price is a critical factor.
But over time, it's more likely waiting will result in a higher price far more often that a lower price. (This is why mathematically lump sum typically comes out ahead.)
So the discipline of investing as the money is available is the default way of buying at the lowest price possible (on average, over the long term).
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Got it! Makes total sense. Thank you.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I agree with the points SnowBog has been making.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:43 pm
Well, 30/70 is a target. My thought was to mosey on toward it gradually.
It might be helpful to regularly track what your current asset allocation actually is.
For example, what is you actual AA right now? (% stocks/bonds/cash)
If the market didn't move in six months (we know it will, but since we don't know which way or how much, pretend for a moment that it won't), what will your AA be if you follow your current plan, including 401k contributions, IRA, more cash accumulating, etc?
Basically, take a look at where you really are now, and how long your plan will take you to mosey gradually to 30/70. I haven't been following your posts closely enough to do the math, but I suspect you are nowhere near 30/70 yet and your moseying will take you quite a while to get close to it. (Though if the market increases a bunch, that may help you get closer a little bit faster.) That's OK if slowly is really what you want, but be sure you've run the math to know how slowly (or quickly) you are actually moseying towards your target.
best wishes,
cj
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
It depends how you calculate it. Very generally if you just count my 401k I’m at around 23/77percent going to 30/70, not so bad. I readjusted my future allocation to 30/70.
If you also include my bank cash, ibonds and IRA (ie, total portfolio), I’m at around 15/85. This will become “worse” as the year goes on (absent a major crash) since cash is still “accumulating” (being earned, although perhaps not in the salt mines) and my expenditures are minimal.
I’m going to post on 2/2 with complete 1/31 numbers and new 2022 projected total comp to set the course. I’ve been busy this month maxing my ibonds and my IRA, now investing the IRA, developing nerves of steel w the volatility and getting more familiar with the fidelity website.
If you also include my bank cash, ibonds and IRA (ie, total portfolio), I’m at around 15/85. This will become “worse” as the year goes on (absent a major crash) since cash is still “accumulating” (being earned, although perhaps not in the salt mines) and my expenditures are minimal.
I’m going to post on 2/2 with complete 1/31 numbers and new 2022 projected total comp to set the course. I’ve been busy this month maxing my ibonds and my IRA, now investing the IRA, developing nerves of steel w the volatility and getting more familiar with the fidelity website.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Thanks for this. Meant to say that earlier. Thanks for the supportiveness.CurlyDave wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 11:23 amOnly? ONLY !!???AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Tue Jan 18, 2022 9:14 pm
...At 55, coming from kinda maybe close to poverty for US standards (which is likely where my optimism deficiency comes from), with maybe 5 more salary earning years if I’m lucky...I only have $1.86 million to my name, 1/3 of which is in my house, plus a tiny pension and SS, neither guaranteed. I thought 1.86 million was freaking amazing but yikes no it isn’t...
https://dqydj.com/average-median-top-n ... centiles/
Look at the link. Not the best one, just the first one I could find. Coming from close to poverty to solidly in the 90+ percentile of household wealth as a single person is a very solid accomplishment.
Could it be better, of course it could -- we all can do better. But the fact that you got to where you are and are going to do better in the future is a great success story.
Find those same net worth brackets for the entire world instead of the US and you are in the 99th percentile.
The people on this board are self-selected "Prodigious Accumulators of Wealth", a tough group to compare your accomplishments against.
-
- Posts: 3286
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2018 6:10 pm
- Location: NYC
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
You win some and you loose some, buy and sell more "Random Walk" heads or tails will come, your time in the market will work in your favor ascending market.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Tue Jan 18, 2022 9:14 pm I’m not challenging the philosophy, just explaining where Im coming from. I get that I’m wrong, and I expect with time I’ll feel more comfortable. I’ve made a LOT of positive changes this year and market timing seems like the last balustrade or whatever. That and maybe cash back cards. I earned 36k in my 401k this year because you all stopped me from selling my equity stake.
At 55, coming from kinda maybe close to poverty for US standards (which is likely where my optimism deficiency comes from), with maybe 5 more salary earning years if I’m lucky, and having pretty much wrecked my first 40 years by being too conservative, and really not having anything else to a certainty as a Plan B, I’d be destroyed financially and emotionally if I lump summed my cash into total market (which Morningstar rates as a fairly high risk investment) and it went down on a prolonged basis. I turned so many needy friends away at the door in 2001 and 2008 - it was awful and I’ll never forget them.
I always look at the 5 year performance charts to get some perspective on the price trajectory. And in light of its history, I think FSKAX is more likely to go down from here than up for various reasons, including geopolitical risks. I don’t mind losing the $500 or so gains by delaying. I did put 3500 into FSKAX in autumn 2021 and it’s down so far. I’m more concerned about staying financially comfortable and preserving what I’ve earned so far.
I described the fear to my brother as being like standing on top of Niagara Falls, about to throw money down. I could lose it… don’t want to lose it. I get that I am losing to inflation. I hedge against the likelihood of being wrong, so I will lump sum some amount in soon, if only to test it.
I only have $1.86 million to my name, 1/3 of which is in my house, plus a tiny pension and SS, neither guaranteed. I thought 1.86 million was freaking amazing but yikes no it isn’t, I’ve learned. Plus yes I want to brag at cocktail parties if I ever attend one again that I bought the dip [OT comment removed by admin LadyGeek].
You are upper middle class professional, don't get hung up on loses it is a mind set you need to learn to shift.
Crash- glass half full? or future discount?
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
All financial assets should be included. 15/85 is your current AA based on what you're saying.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 1:07 pm It depends how you calculate it. Very generally if you just count my 401k I’m at around 23/77percent going to 30/70, not so bad. I readjusted my future allocation to 30/70.
If you also include my bank cash, ibonds and IRA (ie, total portfolio), I’m at around 15/85. This will become “worse” as the year goes on (absent a major crash) since cash is still “accumulating” (being earned, although perhaps not in the salt mines) and my expenditures are minimal.
I’m going to post on 2/2 with complete 1/31 numbers and new 2022 projected total comp to set the course. I’ve been busy this month maxing my ibonds and my IRA, now investing the IRA, developing nerves of steel w the volatility and getting more familiar with the fidelity website.
If 15/85 is getting "worse," we see that the pace of your DCA isn't fast enough. SnowBog and I mentioned 20K/mo; this isn't a joke, this is the kind of pace we're really talking about.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Investing $20,000 in a single month seemed quite unrealistic to me until I realized that I’ve already invested $18,500 this month alone so far (actually over 20k if you count my 401k!):
2022 $10k into ibonds
2022 $7k Roth - into a Fidelity core fund awaiting further investment into FSKAX
1.5k from my 2021 Roth IRA into FSKAX
Naturally this is bond heavy (making things “worse” from an AA perspective) but on 2/2 it will be good to see my 1/31 specific numbers. Maybe there will be a little positive news in those numbers to give me more confidence about bolder steps ahead.
I do have practice now with the ibonds and IRA investing around 10k per month. So perhaps it’s achievable after all…
2022 $10k into ibonds
2022 $7k Roth - into a Fidelity core fund awaiting further investment into FSKAX
1.5k from my 2021 Roth IRA into FSKAX
Naturally this is bond heavy (making things “worse” from an AA perspective) but on 2/2 it will be good to see my 1/31 specific numbers. Maybe there will be a little positive news in those numbers to give me more confidence about bolder steps ahead.
I do have practice now with the ibonds and IRA investing around 10k per month. So perhaps it’s achievable after all…
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
+1 With the assumption that your AA should be 30/70. [Your AA is your entire investment portfolio, which is made up of whatever parts that includes with however they are invested.]
And again, it's not "investing $20k a month" (or similar) as much as it is "I need to transfer these funds from my right pocket to my left pocket to make sure the weight is distributed as I want".
You aren't going to get to an AA of 30/70 with a starting point of 15/85 with $1.8M, with the 85% growing ever bigger, by going slowly...
And again, it's not "investing $20k a month" (or similar) as much as it is "I need to transfer these funds from my right pocket to my left pocket to make sure the weight is distributed as I want".
You aren't going to get to an AA of 30/70 with a starting point of 15/85 with $1.8M, with the 85% growing ever bigger, by going slowly...
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I'm sensing the OP needs to evaluate their ability, need or willingness to take risk. I struggle to see all 3 checkboxes checked.SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 2:56 pm +1 With the assumption that your AA should be 30/70. [Your AA is your entire investment portfolio, which is made up of whatever parts that includes with however they are invested.]
And again, it's not "investing $20k a month" (or similar) as much as it is "I need to transfer these funds from my right pocket to my left pocket to make sure the weight is distributed as I want".
You aren't going to get to an AA of 30/70 with a starting point of 15/85 with $1.8M, with the 85% growing ever bigger, by going slowly...
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
To OP's credit, especially if you've followed this thread, and some of their other ones, they are at the start of a journey.
I think they've been rationale, thoughtful, and disciplined in figuring out how to start on that journey. IIRC they even acknowledged earlier that it was going to take some changes on their side to get to an AA of 30/70.
But assuming that OP is now:
For myself, when I found BH a few years ago, my first steps were really scary. Ignoring employer stock and a few random purchases, I'd never "invested" before in taxable, accepted the "default" option in my 401k, had no clue I could even have a Roth account (let alone years of Mega Backdoor Roth I missed), didn't know what an AA was, or why bonds might be helpful (or frankly what the heck a bond was), and a great many other gaps. I full on admit I was financially illiterate at the time.
So I get it...
Again, to their credit, with their high savings (high income + exceeding low spending especially for NYC), using basically nothing but "cash", having amassed something like $1.2M (ignoring the house value) is extraordinary!
They've been losing money due to inflation, and having to work extra hard to earn/save more. Now it's time to let some of that money do the hard work! Get some invested, let it do its job and start enjoying the wonders of compound inflation interest!
I get the sense that with a little encouragement, we'll help AnnetteLouisan go from baby steps to full speed on their path to a better financial outlook. But those initial few steps are the hardest...
I think they've been rationale, thoughtful, and disciplined in figuring out how to start on that journey. IIRC they even acknowledged earlier that it was going to take some changes on their side to get to an AA of 30/70.
But assuming that OP is now:
- Comfortable with their 30/70 AA
- Confident in their fund selection and placement (such as FSKAX in Roth)
- Ideally, has created an Investor Policy Statement, so they are clear about their own goals, objectives, etc.
For myself, when I found BH a few years ago, my first steps were really scary. Ignoring employer stock and a few random purchases, I'd never "invested" before in taxable, accepted the "default" option in my 401k, had no clue I could even have a Roth account (let alone years of Mega Backdoor Roth I missed), didn't know what an AA was, or why bonds might be helpful (or frankly what the heck a bond was), and a great many other gaps. I full on admit I was financially illiterate at the time.
So I get it...
Again, to their credit, with their high savings (high income + exceeding low spending especially for NYC), using basically nothing but "cash", having amassed something like $1.2M (ignoring the house value) is extraordinary!
They've been losing money due to inflation, and having to work extra hard to earn/save more. Now it's time to let some of that money do the hard work! Get some invested, let it do its job and start enjoying the wonders of compound inflation interest!
I get the sense that with a little encouragement, we'll help AnnetteLouisan go from baby steps to full speed on their path to a better financial outlook. But those initial few steps are the hardest...
Last edited by SnowBog on Thu Jan 20, 2022 4:42 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
This is like one of those music videos with stacks of hundreds getting tossed around.retired@50 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:40 pmOf course it's allowed. I've moved over $500,000 in a single day for my father in law at Vanguard. It's your money after all.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
Regards,
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Indeed, Snowbog! So well said.SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 4:33 pm To OP's credit, especially if you've followed this thread, and some of their other ones, they are at the start of a journey.
I think they've been rationale, thoughtful, and disciplined in figuring out how to start on that journey. IIRC they even acknowledged earlier that it was going to take some changes on their side to get to an AA of 30/70.
But assuming that OP is now:Then it's time to "execute the plan".
- Comfortable with their 30/70 AA
- Confident in their fund selection and placement (such as FSKAX in Roth)
- Ideally, has created an Investor Policy Statement, so they are clear about their own goals, objectives, etc.
For myself, when I found BH a few years ago, my first steps were really scary. Ignoring employer stock and a few random purchases, I'd never "invested" before in taxable, accepted the "default" option in my 401k, had no clue I could even have a Roth account (let alone years of Mega Backdoor Roth I missed), didn't know what an AA was, or why bonds might be helpful (or frankly what the heck a bond was), and a great many other gaps. I full on admit I was financially illiterate at the time.
So I get it...
Again, to their credit, with their high savings (high income + exceeding low spending especially for NYC), using basically nothing but "cash", having amassed something like $1.2M (ignoring the house value) is extraordinary!
They've been losing money due to inflation, and having to work extra hard to earn/save more. Now it's time to let some of that money do the hard work! Get some invested, let it do its job and start enjoying the wonders of compound inflation!
I get the sense that with a little encouragement, we'll help AnnetteLouisan go from baby steps to full speed on their path to a better financial outlook. But those initial few steps are the hardest...
And my IPS is further up in the thread but will be updated.
-
- Posts: 3286
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2018 6:10 pm
- Location: NYC
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I’ve moved 1.7 million last August 2021 and brought on a dip in Sept 2021.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 4:33 pmThis is like one of those music videos with stacks of hundreds getting tossed around.retired@50 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:40 pmOf course it's allowed. I've moved over $500,000 in a single day for my father in law at Vanguard. It's your money after all.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Wed Jan 19, 2022 7:37 pm I’m not going to do $200k tomorrow - or 20k a month - although I see your reasoning, but just out of curiosity, is that even allowed? To do that online in a Fidelity account in one day? There are no safeguards built in to protect someone from themselves? I mean obviously one would have to fund it, but no one would step and say, “hey grandma, how’s it going? Everything ok?”
Regards,
Today’s levels approaching Oct 4, 2021 levels for me.
I may deploy my remaining 100k
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I agree with all of the above, well said!SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 4:33 pm To OP's credit, especially if you've followed this thread, and some of their other ones, they are at the start of a journey.
I think they've been rationale, thoughtful, and disciplined in figuring out how to start on that journey. IIRC they even acknowledged earlier that it was going to take some changes on their side to get to an AA of 30/70.
But assuming that OP is now:Then it's time to "execute the plan".
- Comfortable with their 30/70 AA
- Confident in their fund selection and placement (such as FSKAX in Roth)
- Ideally, has created an Investor Policy Statement, so they are clear about their own goals, objectives, etc.
For myself, when I found BH a few years ago, my first steps were really scary. Ignoring employer stock and a few random purchases, I'd never "invested" before in taxable, accepted the "default" option in my 401k, had no clue I could even have a Roth account (let alone years of Mega Backdoor Roth I missed), didn't know what an AA was, or why bonds might be helpful (or frankly what the heck a bond was), and a great many other gaps. I full on admit I was financially illiterate at the time.
So I get it...
Again, to their credit, with their high savings (high income + exceeding low spending especially for NYC), using basically nothing but "cash", having amassed something like $1.2M (ignoring the house value) is extraordinary!
They've been losing money due to inflation, and having to work extra hard to earn/save more. Now it's time to let some of that money do the hard work! Get some invested, let it do its job and start enjoying the wonders of compound inflation interest!
I get the sense that with a little encouragement, we'll help AnnetteLouisan go from baby steps to full speed on their path to a better financial outlook. But those initial few steps are the hardest...
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
You have a point Marseille07.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 3:00 pmI'm sensing the OP needs to evaluate their ability, need or willingness to take risk. I struggle to see all 3 checkboxes checked.SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 2:56 pm +1 With the assumption that your AA should be 30/70. [Your AA is your entire investment portfolio, which is made up of whatever parts that includes with however they are invested.]
And again, it's not "investing $20k a month" (or similar) as much as it is "I need to transfer these funds from my right pocket to my left pocket to make sure the weight is distributed as I want".
You aren't going to get to an AA of 30/70 with a starting point of 15/85 with $1.8M, with the 85% growing ever bigger, by going slowly...
Ability to take risk? Yes.
Need? Arguably, yes.
Willingness? Yes, SOME risk. Not a lot though. Problem is there is no way to avoid all risk so 25-30 percent equities helps address inflation and interest rate risk.
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Let us know if we can help you execute the plan. SnowBog and I presented a 20K/mo idea and we believe this pace is very reasonable.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 6:53 pmYou have a point Marseille07.Marseille07 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 3:00 pmI'm sensing the OP needs to evaluate their ability, need or willingness to take risk. I struggle to see all 3 checkboxes checked.SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 2:56 pm +1 With the assumption that your AA should be 30/70. [Your AA is your entire investment portfolio, which is made up of whatever parts that includes with however they are invested.]
And again, it's not "investing $20k a month" (or similar) as much as it is "I need to transfer these funds from my right pocket to my left pocket to make sure the weight is distributed as I want".
You aren't going to get to an AA of 30/70 with a starting point of 15/85 with $1.8M, with the 85% growing ever bigger, by going slowly...
Ability to take risk? Yes.
Need? Arguably, yes.
Willingness? Yes, SOME risk. Not a lot though. Problem is there is no way to avoid all risk so 25-30 percent equities helps address inflation and interest rate risk.
If the number seems big, you can rephrase it as 5K/week
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
To be concise, and maybe a little too direct, I think you should get over your discomfort with investing 20k per month.
It's just a number, and if you're accumulating cash so fast that you will never even reach a 30/70 portfolio, you may be being a bit too conservative.
Another way of thinking about this is that you believe you are hesitating to "invest" this 200k, but in reality you have already invested it. You've invested it in cash, which so far has lost 6% in purchasing power in the last year, while stocks went up 12%.
I'm not suggesting that the past 1-year performance is the best way to make decisions, or that you should be all in stocks, but if you want to be 30/70 for the long-term, you should be 30/70 today. Delaying is costing you real money in future returns. I like the idea of 100k today, and 100k over 6 months as a conservative approach
It's just a number, and if you're accumulating cash so fast that you will never even reach a 30/70 portfolio, you may be being a bit too conservative.
Another way of thinking about this is that you believe you are hesitating to "invest" this 200k, but in reality you have already invested it. You've invested it in cash, which so far has lost 6% in purchasing power in the last year, while stocks went up 12%.
I'm not suggesting that the past 1-year performance is the best way to make decisions, or that you should be all in stocks, but if you want to be 30/70 for the long-term, you should be 30/70 today. Delaying is costing you real money in future returns. I like the idea of 100k today, and 100k over 6 months as a conservative approach
Crom laughs at your Four Winds
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
This poster brings up a good point. Yes, the cash is already allocated as part of 15/85; basically this whole exercise is rebalancing from 15/85 to 30/70.muffins14 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 7:29 pm To be concise, and maybe a little too direct, I think you should get over your discomfort with investing 20k per month.
It's just a number, and if you're accumulating cash so fast that you will never even reach a 30/70 portfolio, you may be being a bit too conservative.
Another way of thinking about this is that you believe you are hesitating to "invest" this 200k, but in reality you have already invested it. You've invested it in cash, which so far has lost 6% in purchasing power in the last year, while stocks went up 12%.
I'm not suggesting that the past 1-year performance is the best way to make decisions, or that you should be all in stocks, but if you want to be 30/70 for the long-term, you should be 30/70 today. Delaying is costing you real money in future returns. I like the idea of 100k today, and 100k over 6 months as a conservative approach
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
And food for thought... With the recent market drop, we are approaching the prices from Oct. 2021.
This is one of those "glass half full" vs. "glass half empty" moments.
The "glass half empty" side, will be worried that the market will continue to fall (and it very well might), the price is still too high, etc. You'll find reasons to delay investing - what about this geopolitical thing, or this domestic item, or did you hear the news about the new...
The "glass half full" side would be going "wholly cow - this is great - I can invest at Oct. 2021 prices!!!" And you'd jump at the chance to make quick progress towards your target AA, knowing that you rarely get a chance to buy at the price things were 3 months ago...
And to be transparent, for all we know this is the start of a 2-year market downturn, where we'll see prices continue to fall - and you'll hate all of us for "forcing you in the market". We don't know. We never know. One of the Bogleheads principles is "don't time the market" - as that's a fool's game. If you are comfortable with your AA, the markets are going to do what they are going to do. Your job is to let them do what they are going to do! You "stay the course" with the AA you set, do not panic and sell thinking you'll "wait and get back in" - that always ends badly. Consistently, over the long-term, the markets go up. The ride can be bumpy, but they go up. When you buy a total stock market fund - all you care about is where does it end up 10+ years from now when I need the money. The rest is "noise"...
This is one of those "glass half full" vs. "glass half empty" moments.
The "glass half empty" side, will be worried that the market will continue to fall (and it very well might), the price is still too high, etc. You'll find reasons to delay investing - what about this geopolitical thing, or this domestic item, or did you hear the news about the new...
The "glass half full" side would be going "wholly cow - this is great - I can invest at Oct. 2021 prices!!!" And you'd jump at the chance to make quick progress towards your target AA, knowing that you rarely get a chance to buy at the price things were 3 months ago...
And to be transparent, for all we know this is the start of a 2-year market downturn, where we'll see prices continue to fall - and you'll hate all of us for "forcing you in the market". We don't know. We never know. One of the Bogleheads principles is "don't time the market" - as that's a fool's game. If you are comfortable with your AA, the markets are going to do what they are going to do. Your job is to let them do what they are going to do! You "stay the course" with the AA you set, do not panic and sell thinking you'll "wait and get back in" - that always ends badly. Consistently, over the long-term, the markets go up. The ride can be bumpy, but they go up. When you buy a total stock market fund - all you care about is where does it end up 10+ years from now when I need the money. The rest is "noise"...
- AnnetteLouisan
- Posts: 7263
- Joined: Sat Sep 18, 2021 10:16 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Oh yeah, no - please don’t worry that I will blame anyone for “forcing” me. I don’t move a literal nickel (or do anything else quite frankly) without 100 percent owning the decision. I totally understand no one can predict where the markets will go.
To the contrary I greatly appreciate everyone’s time, explanations and eagerness to show me the path. I’ll get there eventually.
While we’re on the topic, I placed an order for FSKAX at its then current price of 127 a few days ago and it executed at 126.4, to my benefit. But I assume it could go the other way too, right? Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
To the contrary I greatly appreciate everyone’s time, explanations and eagerness to show me the path. I’ll get there eventually.
While we’re on the topic, I placed an order for FSKAX at its then current price of 127 a few days ago and it executed at 126.4, to my benefit. But I assume it could go the other way too, right? Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
- retired@50
- Posts: 12830
- Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2019 2:36 pm
- Location: Living in the U.S.A.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
It depends on the order type. Market, limit, etc.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 8:16 pm Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
See link: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Order
Edited to add, using mutual funds, the order type isn't relevant as all orders execute at end of day NAV price. You have no choice in this matter. Order types only refer to stocks and ETFs.
Regards,
If liberty means anything at all it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear. -George Orwell
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I do (now). The market is what it is.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 8:16 pm Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
But when I started "investing" (meaning I picked the fund and executed the order vs. my 401k doing it for me), I was like you. I wanted to buy at a specific price. And I saw my orders not execute... Again, and again. Then I saw the light.
Part of it is I realized the "price" never bothered me when my 401k transaction happened. It was simply investing the new money available at the current price. Why should it be different when I'm investing?
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
The price is the price is the price. If you waited a day, maybe you would have saved an extra dollar, or maybe if you waited a day it would have lost you a dollar if stocks rose over night. There are too many moment-to-moment changes, so I just invest whenever I have a moment and don't worry about it.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 8:16 pm Oh yeah, no - please don’t worry that I will blame anyone for “forcing” me. I don’t move a literal nickel (or do anything else quite frankly) without 100 percent owning the decision. I totally understand no one can predict where the markets will go.
To the contrary I greatly appreciate everyone’s time, explanations and eagerness to show me the path. I’ll get there eventually.
While we’re on the topic, I placed an order for FSKAX at its then current price of 127 a few days ago and it executed at 126.4, to my benefit. But I assume it could go the other way too, right? Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
Usually I invest biweekly, but sometimes I invest a couple days "early" if there's a dip, and let my incoming paycheck replenish the cash that used to be there.
Crom laughs at your Four Winds
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
With mutual funds, there is just one price per day, the end of day NAV. You won't know exactly what it will be when you place your order, since the final value for it is calculated shortly after the markets close for the day. You need to be OK with that when buying or selling mutual funds. If you want, you can get a reasonable estimate of how the mutual fund is doing that day by looking at a corresponding ETF, especially towards the end of the trading day, but really there is no need to do that (unless perhaps you are tax loss harvesting some day in the future, and really need to a good estimate of current price vs your cost basis). And sometimes prices do move up or down in the last few minutes of a trading day, so an estimate can still be off. Everyone buying (or selling) shares of a given mutual fund on a given day gets the same price.AnnetteLouisan wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 8:16 pm
While we’re on the topic, I placed an order for FSKAX at its then current price of 127 a few days ago and it executed at 126.4, to my benefit. But I assume it could go the other way too, right? Do we just accept the risk of the execution price being higher than when we ordered?
ETF prices vary minute by minute (even second by second) throughout the trading day. There are many possible prices per day, and what moment you pick to place your order can affect your price. And so this is where you need to at least understand market vs. limit orders, etc, and know what you are doing with your order types when you buy or sell ETFs. Some days the market is up a bit for part of the day and then down, or the opposite, etc. So two people are likely to get two different prices for ETF shares bought on the same day, unless they both pick the same moment to buy.
As a non-market timer, I find the one price per day aspect of mutual funds to be quite helpful. There's no need for me to worry about it, the only decision is whether to invest that day or not, so it really simplifies things. And with a mutual fund, I can even put in an order to buy the night before, or on the weekend, or schedule ahead of time for a particular date. If I put in an order while the market is closed, I'll get the closing price for the next day the market is open, or for the date that I've scheduled an automated investment.
I hope that helps!
cj
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
You want to craft a plan and stick with it. If 20K/mo seems a lot, then 10K/mo? 5K/mo? Whatever it is, you want to come up with something and follow through. I am not going to get into the exact figure, but can tell you I've deployed more than 20K this month myself.
-
- Posts: 3286
- Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2018 6:10 pm
- Location: NYC
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
Annette
Warren Buffett once said that it is wise for investors to be “fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful.”
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/i ... greedy.asp
Warren Buffett once said that it is wise for investors to be “fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful.”
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/i ... greedy.asp
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
+1000!!!Marseille07 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 9:40 pm You want to craft a plan and stick with it. If 20K/mo seems a lot, then 10K/mo? 5K/mo? Whatever it is, you want to come up with something and follow through. I am not going to get into the exact figure...
If the plan is set, move to executive phase!
-
- Posts: 16054
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2020 12:41 pm
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I don't think the plan is set yet, though I don't know what they're struggling with. We've shown the math and I don't think 20K/mo is crazy.SnowBog wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 10:32 pm+1000!!!Marseille07 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 20, 2022 9:40 pm You want to craft a plan and stick with it. If 20K/mo seems a lot, then 10K/mo? 5K/mo? Whatever it is, you want to come up with something and follow through. I am not going to get into the exact figure...
If the plan is set, move to executive phase!
To put it differently, if they think 20K/mo is too much and can only do 5K/mo, then wherever 5K/mo takes them by the end of 2022 might be their target AA.
Re: Where Do I Go From Here - Asset Location [2022 Update]
I was meaning the broader plan... More the "strategy" side of things.
AA - check
$ needed tuition get to AA - check (or close to)
Fund selection - check (or I think so away)
I view "execution" as the mechanics of delivering on the plan. So figuring out the $ and frequency I consider more "execution" things (as they don't change the plan/strategy).
But there is an argument to make that lump sum vs. DCA, and/or different speeds of DCA might be part of the "plan" phase...
AA - check
$ needed tuition get to AA - check (or close to)
Fund selection - check (or I think so away)
I view "execution" as the mechanics of delivering on the plan. So figuring out the $ and frequency I consider more "execution" things (as they don't change the plan/strategy).
But there is an argument to make that lump sum vs. DCA, and/or different speeds of DCA might be part of the "plan" phase...