Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
-
- Posts: 136
- Joined: Fri Dec 04, 2020 9:46 am
Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
I am retired 60, wife is 61. Wife in school studying for masters #3. Current net worth $4.5mm. 2 college age children both living on their own in apartments in college towns. I have 529s fully funded for all 3 “students”. We have helped the kids save and invest well. They both have nice start to life $ in brokerage accts and Roth. Sold our home 1 year ago for substantial gain, renting for now in HCOL area. Rent is painful $5750 mo. No other debt. Asset allocation is 55/45 VTI/cash & ultra short. I keep $ for next home in MM. I am not including this $ in our net worth or AA. ($1.8-2mm set aside if we stay in this area). If we move to MCOL we would have surplus from this $ towards retirement.
Taxable 2.5mm
TIRA 2mm
Considering Roth conversions but need to utilize ACA for now. Deferring SS until 70 for me and 68 for wife. Small pensions and SS will add $68k annually at that point. Expenses about 140k per year. Retirement expenses planning 135-175k. $4.5mm x 3% = 135k so we should be fine and even better when RMD, SS, pensions begins.
We most likely will stay in this area until the kids are older and get started in their careers. 2-5 years. And wife has more school to complete. But wife loves it here so we may always have a home near here. So what to do?? There is no rental inventory in the Bay Area. None, especially in our County. We will not find a cheaper option. So there is no “move to a cheaper rental”. If we stay and don’t buy a home we bleed away all this rental cost. I’m a value investor in all things so would not consider buying a home in this inflated real estate market. And time horizon may be too short to purchase home. If home prices come down it will probably take 2-3 years for them to reset. If they hold we are wasting a lot of capital by renting.
What would you do?
Taxable 2.5mm
TIRA 2mm
Considering Roth conversions but need to utilize ACA for now. Deferring SS until 70 for me and 68 for wife. Small pensions and SS will add $68k annually at that point. Expenses about 140k per year. Retirement expenses planning 135-175k. $4.5mm x 3% = 135k so we should be fine and even better when RMD, SS, pensions begins.
We most likely will stay in this area until the kids are older and get started in their careers. 2-5 years. And wife has more school to complete. But wife loves it here so we may always have a home near here. So what to do?? There is no rental inventory in the Bay Area. None, especially in our County. We will not find a cheaper option. So there is no “move to a cheaper rental”. If we stay and don’t buy a home we bleed away all this rental cost. I’m a value investor in all things so would not consider buying a home in this inflated real estate market. And time horizon may be too short to purchase home. If home prices come down it will probably take 2-3 years for them to reset. If they hold we are wasting a lot of capital by renting.
What would you do?
-
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2021 6:13 am
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
Very personal decision.
To me the variable is your time horizon 2 -5 years.
If I thought 2 years, I'd pay the rent and forget it.
If I thought 5 years, I'd look at comfortable commuting distance for your wife's program, try and take an honest assessment on the size and amenities you need, and see what I could get on the condo market.
To me the variable is your time horizon 2 -5 years.
If I thought 2 years, I'd pay the rent and forget it.
If I thought 5 years, I'd look at comfortable commuting distance for your wife's program, try and take an honest assessment on the size and amenities you need, and see what I could get on the condo market.
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
With $6.5M you can do whatever you want.
I'm not sure why you sold the former house? Seems almost like you are second guessing that decision. What was the plan at the time, and what has changed to cause you to question the original strategy?
I'm not sure why you sold the former house? Seems almost like you are second guessing that decision. What was the plan at the time, and what has changed to cause you to question the original strategy?
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
I am no expert on CA real estate taxes (I think by "Bay Area" you mean you live in CA), but won't you have a quite large property tax bill on a newly purchased ~$2mill property? My back of the envelope calculation comes up with something like $38K/year, or ~$3k/month. And if you invested the $2mill in index funds, the dividends would probably be another $3k/month. So that $5750 rent doesn't look quite so bad if you compare it to the costs of owning your own home? You should run your own numbers, of course.
Seems like a personal decision, anyway. There are lots of pros and cons. I used to live in the Bay Area (CA) and am familiar with both its good points and its bad points. I ended up relocating to New Mexico in 2006 after living the Bay Area (Palo Alto, Mountain View, Livermore) for 13 years, and have no regrets.
Certainly if you do relocate to a MCOL area after your wife finishes school, then your portfolio is more than sufficient!
edit: typo
Seems like a personal decision, anyway. There are lots of pros and cons. I used to live in the Bay Area (CA) and am familiar with both its good points and its bad points. I ended up relocating to New Mexico in 2006 after living the Bay Area (Palo Alto, Mountain View, Livermore) for 13 years, and have no regrets.
Certainly if you do relocate to a MCOL area after your wife finishes school, then your portfolio is more than sufficient!
edit: typo
Last edited by NancyABQ on Sun Jul 25, 2021 11:15 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 136
- Joined: Fri Dec 04, 2020 9:46 am
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
With kids off to college we were able to monetize our primary home. Did not want to live there due to traffic and knew we did not want to be there long term. Fire risk was as issue. 1 way in and 1 way out. The new reality we live in. With 2-5 yr horizon we are leaving that $ in cash. NEVER invest in mutual fund or etf's with less than that time horizon.
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
If there is something that you are unhappy with about your current rental then you might consider a more expensive rental since you can likely afford it and it sounds like you will only need it for a few years.
If the place you are renting is equevelent to a $2 million property you might buy then I would cruch the numbers hard since at least financially that could be a better deal than buying similar property.
Becoming a life long renter could make sense and that works for some people.
- RickBoglehead
- Posts: 7877
- Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2018 8:10 am
- Location: In a house
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
$6.5 million.
"If we stay and don’t buy a home we bleed away all this rental cost". $69,000 a year is "bleeding"? You have 26 years of rent, assuming your $1.8 million didn't grow at all. Putting it in the market, you'd easily cover rent and taxes on the earnings.
"If we stay and don’t buy a home we bleed away all this rental cost". $69,000 a year is "bleeding"? You have 26 years of rent, assuming your $1.8 million didn't grow at all. Putting it in the market, you'd easily cover rent and taxes on the earnings.
Avid user of forums on variety of interests-financial, home brewing, F-150, EV, home repair, etc. Enjoy learning & passing on knowledge. It's PRINCIPAL, not PRINCIPLE. I ADVISE you to seek ADVICE.
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
If you invest the 2M according to AA then to match 69k rent you would need about 3.4% return which is not unreasonable for a long time horizon.
You also have the cash to buy the home.
It sounds like that you are very likely to stay in this area but not certain. Perhaps wait for couple of years and continue to rent then decide whether you want to buy home? Maybe discuss with the spouse?
I would think that you would want to buy a home at some point of time instead of being a renter for the rest of the life?
I would probably invest half of that 2M.
You also have the cash to buy the home.
It sounds like that you are very likely to stay in this area but not certain. Perhaps wait for couple of years and continue to rent then decide whether you want to buy home? Maybe discuss with the spouse?
I would think that you would want to buy a home at some point of time instead of being a renter for the rest of the life?
I would probably invest half of that 2M.
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
OP might be eligible under new propositions 60/90/19 to transfer tax base if bought with in 2 years. I am not sure about all the ins and outs. Probably something OP should keep in mindNancyABQ wrote: ↑Sun Jul 25, 2021 11:01 am I am no expert on CA real estate taxes (I think by "Bay Area" you mean you live in CA), but won't you have a quite large property tax bill on a newly purchased ~$2mill property? My back of the envelope calculation comes up with something like $38K/year, or ~$3k/month. And if you invested the $2mill in index funds, the dividends would probably be another $3k/month. So that $5750 rent doesn't look quite so bad if you compare it to the costs of owning your own home? You should run your own numbers, of course.
Seems like a personal decision, anyway. There are lots of pros and cons. I used to live in the Bay Area (CA) and am familiar with both its good points and its bad points. I ended up relocating to New Mexico in 2006 after living the Bay Area (Palo Alto, Mountain View, Livermore) for 13 years, and have no regrets.
Certainly if you do relocate to a MCOL area after your wife finishes school, then your portfolio is more than sufficient!
edit: typo
edit: Also if new value is considered, CA property tax rate is 1.1-1.2% in most cities.
When in doubt, http://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=79939
-
- Posts: 237
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2021 1:33 pm
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
A lot of decisions cannot be made because it seems other people will object (wife, kids). I am afraid you have limited options unless you're willing to rock the boat. I can't tell you what you should do and given your circumstances, I really have no idea what I would do either. My preference would be to not pay for the wife to get a masters degree nor buy a house in the bay area at all.
-
- Posts: 5774
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2014 4:47 pm
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
> Sold our home 1 year ago for substantial gain, renting for now in HCOL area
> There is no rental inventory in the Bay Area
> We most likely will stay in this area until the kids are older and get started in their careers. 2-5 years
Ya done boxed yer'self in.
> There is no rental inventory in the Bay Area
> We most likely will stay in this area until the kids are older and get started in their careers. 2-5 years
Ya done boxed yer'self in.
-
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Sat Dec 12, 2020 11:35 am
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
If you stay in the bay area you are stuck with your current situation. There are many amazing areas of California, within driving distance that would allow you to live way below your means and retain a higher standard of living. However I understand your ties to the bay area.
Many people in your shoes have left California all together.
Many people in your shoes have left California all together.
Re: Sold primary home with gains, now what to do?
If you can still buy a new home within 2 years of the sale, you may be able to transfer your tax base under Prop 90. More info here: https://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/lta21019.pdfray.james wrote: ↑Mon Jul 26, 2021 1:37 amOP might be eligible under new propositions 60/90/19 to transfer tax base if bought with in 2 years. I am not sure about all the ins and outs. Probably something OP should keep in mindNancyABQ wrote: ↑Sun Jul 25, 2021 11:01 am I am no expert on CA real estate taxes (I think by "Bay Area" you mean you live in CA), but won't you have a quite large property tax bill on a newly purchased ~$2mill property? My back of the envelope calculation comes up with something like $38K/year, or ~$3k/month. And if you invested the $2mill in index funds, the dividends would probably be another $3k/month. So that $5750 rent doesn't look quite so bad if you compare it to the costs of owning your own home? You should run your own numbers, of course.
Seems like a personal decision, anyway. There are lots of pros and cons. I used to live in the Bay Area (CA) and am familiar with both its good points and its bad points. I ended up relocating to New Mexico in 2006 after living the Bay Area (Palo Alto, Mountain View, Livermore) for 13 years, and have no regrets.
Certainly if you do relocate to a MCOL area after your wife finishes school, then your portfolio is more than sufficient!
edit: typo
edit: Also if new value is considered, CA property tax rate is 1.1-1.2% in most cities.
The lower property taxes may not be enough to mitigate the possible transaction costs if you don’t end up leaving the area in the next few years.