Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I'm planning on doing a backdoor Roth this month because my income will be too high this year to contribute to a Roth IRA. I have all of my retirement funds in a work 403B, work Roth 457, Roth IRA, with the exception of about $300 in a traditional IRA (which is a remnant from a recharacterization I did many years ago). Reading up on how to proceed, I understand that I need to nix the traditional IRA -- but I am not sure if it would be best to rollover the $300 into my work 403b (my job says it can be done), or just convert the traditional to Roth and pay the tax. What would be the easiest and most cost-effective?
-
- Posts: 8954
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 6:11 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Whatever is easiest. The tax on converting $300 isn’t going to change your life one way or the other.
It will be great to be able to perform the Backdoor Roths. I would say converting the $300 would be much easier and requires substantially less time.
Cheers
It will be great to be able to perform the Backdoor Roths. I would say converting the $300 would be much easier and requires substantially less time.
Cheers
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I’d just convert all... tax on $300 shouldn’t be that much...
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Another vote on convert. Easy peasy, lemon squeezy.
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
If you were to rollover your $300 into your 403b then the pro rata rule would still apply until 2021. So yes, convert it and pay the taxes.
- neurosphere
- Posts: 5205
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 12:55 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I'm not sure that's true. It's the value in the IRA as of Dec 31st that's important. As an example, one could contribute $6000 to IRA #1, convert it to Roth, and then later rollover IRA #2 which already had $$ into a 401k. No tax would be due on the conversion.
If you have to ask "Is a Target Date fund right for me?", the answer is "Yes" (even in taxable accounts).
- neurosphere
- Posts: 5205
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 12:55 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I'm not sure that's true. It's the value in the IRA as of Dec 31st that's important. As an example, one could contribute $6000 to IRA #1, convert it to Roth, and then later rollover IRA #2 which already had $$ into a 401k. No tax would be due on the conversion.
If you have to ask "Is a Target Date fund right for me?", the answer is "Yes" (even in taxable accounts).
-
- Posts: 8954
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 6:11 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
This is not correct. The 403b is not an IRA and therefore the balance after the transaction will have $0 in any IRA on 12/31/2020. The only date that matters is 12/31 of the year in which the Backdoor Roth conversion occurs.
Cheers
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Thanks for all the replies. So How should I proceed? Do I put $6k into the Traditional IRA that contains the $300, and then transfer all of it over to my current Roth IRA?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Sounds good. Quick and easy, and set up for future backdoors as well.
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
By doing this, how is it clear that only the $300 is being taxed for the conversion to Roth, and not the full $6300?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Please work through the Form 8606 manually, and pay special attention on lines 8 and 11 in the form. It is not that difficult, and does not require any other information. You will see that only $300 gets taxedNewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 12:16 am By doing this, how is it clear that only the $300 is being taxed for the conversion to Roth, and not the full $6300?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Thanks.
Do I instruct Vanguard to withold federal income tax?
Do I instruct Vanguard to withold federal income tax?
-
- Posts: 8954
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 6:11 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
No. That way it all goes into the Roth. Just pay the tax on next years return.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 4:17 pm Thanks.
Do I instruct Vanguard to withold federal income tax?
Cheers
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
That would work.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Sun Jan 19, 2020 12:14 am Thanks for all the replies. So How should I proceed? Do I put $6k into the Traditional IRA that contains the $300, and then transfer all of it over to my current Roth IRA?
The Form 8606 takes care of this. Do not venture into backdoor-land without a thorough understanding of this form.By doing this, how is it clear that only the $300 is being taxed for the conversion to Roth, and not the full $6300?
No. That would be an early withdrawal unless you are already 59.5.Do I instruct Vanguard to withold federal income tax?
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Thanks for the replies.
So does Vanguard generate a tax form that I plug into my tax software to account for this? Or do I actually have to fill out that 8606 (just glancing at it makes me sleepy). Thanks!
So does Vanguard generate a tax form that I plug into my tax software to account for this? Or do I actually have to fill out that 8606 (just glancing at it makes me sleepy). Thanks!
-
- Posts: 8954
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 6:11 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Time to step up. Lakpr told you about needing to get familiar with the 8606 and what to pay attention to.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 5:04 pm Thanks for the replies.
So does Vanguard generate a tax form that I plug into my tax software to account for this? Or do I actually have to fill out that 8606 (just glancing at it makes me sleepy). Thanks!
The tax form from VG and your tax software isn’t going to make this happen without your active attention to detail in order to ensure you file the information properly.
Cheers
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
You need to become one with this form.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 5:04 pm Thanks for the replies.
So does Vanguard generate a tax form that I plug into my tax software to account for this? Or do I actually have to fill out that 8606 (just glancing at it makes me sleepy). Thanks!
No. That is not a joke. Vanguard does not send you any form that you just plug in like a 1099. They do not know what you are doing on your taxes.
If you don't understand this process and it's paperwork fully, you will likely just be another person who messes it up and then comes here in a panic to get it fixed 2 years later after getting a letter from the IRS.
This is why I stopped recommending the "back door" several years ago.
Not kidding about that either. Too many people mess it up.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Haha okay guys. I'll have to study the form then.
Another question - if I am not 100% sure I'll be over the income limit that will disqualify me from doing a regular Roth this year, should I just wait to do this at the end of the year?
Another question - if I am not 100% sure I'll be over the income limit that will disqualify me from doing a regular Roth this year, should I just wait to do this at the end of the year?
-
- Posts: 8954
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 6:11 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Convert the $300 tomorrow and put that behind you. Take a little bit of time to familiarize yourself with the 8606 now and then do the Backdoor Roth after that. Delaying is just going to make it harder to do later in the year and you will be back here having to ask questions again.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 6:26 pm Haha okay guys. I'll have to study the form then.
Another question - if I am not 100% sure I'll be over the income limit that will disqualify me from doing a regular Roth this year, should I just wait to do this at the end of the year?
You can do this.
Cheers
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
If you choose to use the back door, that can be done any time...regardless of whether you are over the limit or not.
If you want to try to do a direct contribution, it appears you need to wait til the end of the year and hope your situation is more clear.
If you want to try to do a direct contribution, it appears you need to wait til the end of the year and hope your situation is more clear.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Thanks so much. As I understand it, there would be no downside to doing the backdoor Roth IRA contribution instead of a regular Roth IRA should my income fall below the income limit. Is this correct?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
That is correct. There is no requirement to be over the Roth IRA limit in order to use the back door.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
So I'm reading the instructions and here it reads:
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
In 2019 I converted my Trad IRA to Roth. This past weekend I started to work through Turbo Tax, (VG had the 1099-R ready online) not too difficult and I believe I have it correct. My trad IRA was 2 years old so like you I had some gains but all contribution were non deductible. I converted 100%.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 6:26 pm Haha okay guys. I'll have to study the form then.
Another question - if I am not 100% sure I'll be over the income limit that will disqualify me from doing a regular Roth this year, should I just wait to do this at the end of the year?
Two vids that helped me.
Explains the 8606: (I believe the author is a forum member)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w244kccgl84
Explains Turbo Tax procedure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGvHZqD-QMQ
Last edited by S_Track on Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Deleted duplicate
Last edited by S_Track on Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 11420
- Joined: Thu Dec 27, 2018 2:06 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Yes. I keep the documentation (including 5498/1099R) per the Form 8606 instructions you quoted, above. Scan it and it will take up very little storage space.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:06 pm So I'm reading the instructions and here it reads:
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
So these will need to be furnished for sure, or is it a "just in case" the IRS asks for them?HomeStretch wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:55 pmYes. I keep the documentation (including 5498/1099R) per the Form 8606 instructions you quoted, above. Scan it and it will take up very little storage space.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:06 pm So I'm reading the instructions and here it reads:
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
-
- Posts: 11420
- Joined: Thu Dec 27, 2018 2:06 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Just in case. Burden of proof is on the taxpayer.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 10:12 pmSo these will need to be furnished for sure, or is it a "just in case" the IRS asks for them?HomeStretch wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:55 pmYes. I keep the documentation (including 5498/1099R) per the Form 8606 instructions you quoted, above. Scan it and it will take up very little storage space.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:06 pm So I'm reading the instructions and here it reads:
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Depends on how old you are. And good for you for finding that.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:06 pm Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
If you ever want/need to take money out of Roth IRA before you are 59.5 years old, you have to know the original source and dates of the contributions in order to know if any of your withdrawal is taxable. This is because money is deemed to come out of the Roth IRA in a certain order (not necessarily the same order it went in there). The only way to do that is by having the records.
This website explains.
https://fairmark.com/retirement/roth-ac ... -overview/
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Can't believe I've never seen either of these!S_Track wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:51 pm Two vids that helped me.
Explains the 8606: (I believe the author is a forum member)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w244kccgl84
Explains Turbo Tax procedure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGvHZqD-QMQ
The first one is from White Coat Investor Jim Dahle who is a poster here. I have not watched the whole thing, but it should be correct. Not familiar with the other one.
I'll try to watch each of them soon because these videos could be very helpful in the upcoming months when we have so many questions on this issue.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Hmmm... I would have thought that if I'm submitting a Form 8606 to them year after year, they can refer to their own records if they have any questions.HomeStretch wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 10:55 pmJust in case. Burden of proof is on the taxpayer.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 10:12 pmSo these will need to be furnished for sure, or is it a "just in case" the IRS asks for them?HomeStretch wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:55 pmYes. I keep the documentation (including 5498/1099R) per the Form 8606 instructions you quoted, above. Scan it and it will take up very little storage space.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:06 pm So I'm reading the instructions and here it reads:
"To verify the nontaxable part of distributions from your IRAs, including Roth IRAs, keep a copy of the following forms and records until all distributions are made.
Page 1 of Forms 1040 (or Forms 1040A, 1040NR, or 1040-T) filed for each year you made a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA.
Forms 8606 and any supporting statements, attachments, and worksheets for all applicable years... "
Am I really supposed to hold onto these 8606 forms every year for the next 30 years?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
retiredjg wrote: ↑Tue Jan 21, 2020 6:15 amCan't believe I've never seen either of these!S_Track wrote: ↑Mon Jan 20, 2020 9:51 pm Two vids that helped me.
Explains the 8606: (I believe the author is a forum member)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w244kccgl84
Explains Turbo Tax procedure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGvHZqD-QMQ
The first one is from White Coat Investor Jim Dahle who is a poster here. I have not watched the whole thing, but it should be correct. Not familiar with the other one.
I'll try to watch each of them soon because these videos could be very helpful in the upcoming months when we have so many questions on this issue.
Wow - great links!
I also found this from Credit Karma Tax:
https://support.creditkarma.com/s/artic ... butions-US
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I worked through the Form 8606 (simulation for tax year 2019) but it doesn't look right. Where did I go wrong?
See here: https://ibb.co/vw2XsYH
See here: https://ibb.co/vw2XsYH
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
They say it is ok to round to 3 decimal points, but leave them all in there. That changes the next line to 5,999.99 ($6000) which is what it should be. This also changes line 13, 14, and 17.
Your subtraction of line 17 from line 16 is incorrect. The taxable amount should be $300.
Good for you for doing this ahead of time!
Your subtraction of line 17 from line 16 is incorrect. The taxable amount should be $300.
Good for you for doing this ahead of time!
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I don't think this is about showing them anything.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Tue Jan 21, 2020 9:02 pm Hmmm... I would have thought that if I'm submitting a Form 8606 to them year after year, they can refer to their own records if they have any questions.
Look at the instructions for Form 8606, Part III which is what you use if you take money out of Roth IRA. There is a worksheet in there to determine what might be taxable.
You are keeping all this information in case you ever need to fill out the worksheet....the Form 8606 is one part of that.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Thanks so much, everyone. I think I'm ready to do this.
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
retiredjg wrote: ↑Wed Jan 22, 2020 5:33 am They say it is ok to round to 3 decimal points, but leave them all in there. That changes the next line to 5,999.99 ($6000) which is what it should be. This also changes line 13, 14, and 17.
Your subtraction of line 17 from line 16 is incorrect. The taxable amount should be $300.
Good for you for doing this ahead of time!
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
I think you are too. Wish more people would do that....NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 22, 2020 7:01 pm Thanks so much, everyone. I think I'm ready to do this.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
So at the beginning of this tutorial (https://www.physicianonfire.com/backdoor/), the author states, "I invest my non-deductible IRA contribution in the Prime Money Market Fund so day-to-day volatility is a non-issue."
Why does this matter? It all gets accounted for in Form 8606, right? Is the danger simply that the conversion could trigger a higher-than-anticipated tax?
Why does this matter? It all gets accounted for in Form 8606, right? Is the danger simply that the conversion could trigger a higher-than-anticipated tax?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Yes it should not matter whether the money is in money market fund or a stock fund. I suppose it is just orthodoxy, to make sure whatever you contributed to n-d-tIRA makes it into r-IRA. The likelihood that there will be growth in the account prior to conversion is same as the likelihood that there will be loss in the account, if you invest in a stock fund. Uncle Sam unfortunately won't give you a break for loss in the account prior to Roth conversion.
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
It does all come out in the Form 8606 wash, but there is always the question about what happens if the value goes down instead of up.
Some people believe the unused basis is carried forward for future use and some people believe the unused basis goes poof.
Some people believe the unused basis is carried forward for future use and some people believe the unused basis goes poof.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
- neurosphere
- Posts: 5205
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 12:55 pm
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
But there would be a tax only if there were gains, which would be a good thing unless for some reason that extra income/tax causes problems somewhere else on one's return. The suggestion is for most people just one of simplicity. If there is a gain of zero or a dollar or two, the tax paperwork is very "nice looking". If there is a loss, it adds a line or two to the reporting. In theory, if there are more up days in the market than down days, one should invest in stocks.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Tue Jan 28, 2020 8:47 pm So at the beginning of this tutorial (https://www.physicianonfire.com/backdoor/), the author states, "I invest my non-deductible IRA contribution in the Prime Money Market Fund so day-to-day volatility is a non-issue."
Why does this matter? It all gets accounted for in Form 8606, right? Is the danger simply that the conversion could trigger a higher-than-anticipated tax?
If you have to ask "Is a Target Date fund right for me?", the answer is "Yes" (even in taxable accounts).
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Okay so I guess I’d like to avoid the volatility.
My trad IRA with the $300 is a target 2045 fund.
So I can put the $6k into a prime money market fund for a day, under the same traditional IRA mentioned above, then convert both of these together and at once to my Roth IRA?
My trad IRA with the $300 is a target 2045 fund.
So I can put the $6k into a prime money market fund for a day, under the same traditional IRA mentioned above, then convert both of these together and at once to my Roth IRA?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Yes. And again, good for you for getting the paperwork figured out ahead of time. You will not regret that.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 29, 2020 8:22 am Okay so I guess I’d like to avoid the volatility.
My trad IRA with the $300 is a target 2045 fund.
So I can put the $6k into a prime money market fund for a day, under the same traditional IRA mentioned above, then convert both of these together and at once to my Roth IRA?
On reading your original post again, I wonder if that $300 was deductible way back when? If it was not deductible, you can document that now.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
So I created that traditional IRA (via re-characterization of Roth funds) in order to get below the income threshold that would qualify me for the savers credit several years ago. Therefore it was deductible back then I believe (it got me below the threshold).
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Good. In that case, you should expect to pay tax on only the $300.
Link to Asking Portfolio Questions
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Yes, especially given your other answer that the recharacterization years earlier from Roth to Traditional earned you Savers' Credit. That certainly means the $300 is pre-tax. Just make sure that after the Roth conversion, there is $0 in the traditional IRA. You will owe taxes on the $300.NewbieBogle007 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 29, 2020 8:22 am Okay so I guess I’d like to avoid the volatility.
My trad IRA with the $300 is a target 2045 fund.
So I can put the $6k into a prime money market fund for a day, under the same traditional IRA mentioned above, then convert both of these together and at once to my Roth IRA?
Re: Backdoor Roth - should I convert or rollover my Trad IRA?
Question about converting the $300 to my Roth: Can I convert it under 2019 tax year? My income will be lower in 2019. Also, the $6000 must be converted under the 2020 year since it came from a 2020 contribution, right?